Cyber Pearl Harbor Versus The Real Pearl Harbor -

Cyber Pearl Harbor Versus The Real Pearl Harbor

Credit: forbes.com

  • Dec 07 2017 14:30About: 10 days ago
  • 6 views

Today, December 7, is a good day to re-think the implications of a “cyber Pearl Harbor.”  Leon Panetta, famously used the term in 2011, when it seemed like all of our generals had become cyber experts overnight.

"The potential for the next Pearl Harbor could very well be a cyber-attack," the CIA Director testified before the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence.

At the time Keith Alexander was in the midst of standing up US Cyber Command which achieved operational readiness on October 31, 2010 months before Panetta’s statement.

Panetta, and just about anyone else inside the Beltway uses the term Cyber Pearl Harbor to imply a disabling attack on critical infrastructure. Yes, our power grid, communications, and traffic lights, are very poorly protected from hackers.  Yes, an attack similar to that in Ukraine over Christmas 2015 would not be difficult to achieve. But would it be strategic? What purpose would it serve a foreign government to shut down the power in the United States? Would China want to damage the economy of its biggest market?  Would Russia risk the blow back?  Perhaps Iran or DPRK would figure they had nothing to lose?

Regardless, an attack on critical infrastructure is something for the Department of Homeland Security to worry about. The DoD has bigger worries.

Back before the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, before military thinkers and policymakers became obsessed with counterinsurgency, the idea of the day was the Revolution in Military Affairs, or RMA, a doctrine that emphasized modern information, technology and communications. It was sparked by Soviet analysis of the West’s move towards more reliance on precision targeting and coordination as demonstrated in Operation Desert Storm.

The reclusive and enigmatic “Yoda” of the Pentagon, Andrew Marshall, was pouring through Russian language journals and presumably secret communiques. He was intrigued by the Soviet identification of a “Military Technical Revolution.” Europe throughout the Cold War occupied the center of the chessboard. On one hand, grand strategy revolved around a massive preemptive blitz of tanks and troops supported by air and even tactical nuclear weapons, emanating from the Soviet bloc, and on the other hand, arms buildup and nuclear deterrence from the West.

When Russian and Chinese thinkers witnessed an actual invasion using massed weapons and troops, supported by air and stand-off cruise missiles, as a U.S.-led coalition easily pushed Iraqi forces from Kuwait, they believed they saw the future of modern warfare. A combination of precision-guided weapons, networked intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (ISR), and modern command and control would be a force multiplier while eliminating the fog of war.

Arthur Cebrowski was the chief proponent of the new Network-Centric Warfare (NCW). His 1998 paper, Network-Centric Warfare: Its Origin and Future Proceedings, written while he was still director for Space, Information Warfare, and Command and Control, is imbued with the excitement of the halcyon days of the internet boom. Reading it today, one is struck by the enthusiasm for networking that was the dot-com boom:

“We are in the midst of a revolution in military affairs (RMA) unlike any seen since the Napoleonic Age, when France transformed warfare with the concept of levée en masse. Chief of Naval Operations Admiral Jay Johnson has called it ‘a fundamental shift from what we call platform-centric warfare to something we call network-centric warfare’, and it will prove to be the most important RMA in the past 200 years.”

In his Pentagon briefing upon taking the director of Force Transformation role, Cebrowski said: “If you are not interoperable, you are not on the net. You are not benefiting from the information age.” Cebrowski was the Scott McNealy of the Pentagon.

When modernized militaries next engage in combat, expect a debilitating cyber-attack giving the adversary an asymmetric advantage. The move to Network-centric warfighting by the U.S. military set the stage for an inevitable Cyber Pearl Harbor.

The tenets of NCW, once again, are: Eliminating the fog of war through a sensor grid, and a combination of precision-guided weapons, ISR, and command and control. The U.S. military, and other militaries around the world on both sides, were late to the computer and networking game (now dubbed “cyber”) but determined to catch up. A global information grid was sketched out. Satellites for reconnaissance and communication were launched. Precision GPS systems deployed. Drones for ISR and weapons delivery to targets were built in ever increasing numbers. A high altitude drone, the Global Hawk, was deployed not only to replace the 50s vintage U2 platform but to add a layer to the ISR and command and control from land, sea, and air systems.



Follow Us on Twitter

attack critical infrastructure Pearl Harbor. military defeat cyber means

Related stories with Cyber Pearl Harbor Versus The Real Pearl Harbor

Paul Finebaum likes the Jeremy Pruitt hire but there are some caveats -World News
Paul Finebaum likes the Jeremy Pruitt hire but there are some caveats 10 days ago
Count Paul Finebaum in the camp of those who like Tennessee’s reported hire of Alabama defensive coordinator. But there is a catch “I think Jeremy Pruitt is a good choice when you consider everything that happened here,” Finebaum said. &
Drew McIntyre Back at the Gym Preparing for WWE Return -World News
Drew McIntyre Back at the Gym Preparing for WWE Return 10 days ago
Former WWE NXT Champion Drew McIntyre suffered a serious bicep injury last month and had to undergo surgery. He was expected to be out of action for an indefinite amount of time. It looks like McIntyre is already preparing for a return after undergoing su
Timeline for The Revival’s Return to WWE Programming -World News
Timeline for The Revival’s Return to WWE Programming 10 days ago
According to PWInsider, Scott Dawson is scheduled to return to action in the next 4-6 weeks, just around the time for next month’s Royal Rumble event. Dawson has been out of action after suffering an injury back in August to his right bicep. Dash Wi
The Star Power of Johnny Hallyday (Jimi Hendrix Was His Opening Act) -World News
The Star Power of Johnny Hallyday (Jimi Hendrix Was His Opening Act) 10 days ago
In a previously unpublished interview, the French rock star, who died this week, discussed his favorite musicians, fame and discovering Hendrix in a London club.
Palestinians Vent Their Anger After Trump’s Jerusalem Declaration -World News
Palestinians Vent Their Anger After Trump’s Jerusalem Declaration 10 days ago
Amid predictions of violence and calls by Hamas for a new intifada, protesters in the West Bank and Gaza clashed with Israeli forces.
Even With The Doping Ban, Russia Could Still 'Win' The Olympics. Here's How -World News
Even With The Doping Ban, Russia Could Still 'Win' The Olympics. Here's How 10 days ago
Following allegations of doping, Russia has been banned as a national competitor from the upcoming Winter Olympic Games in South Korea in 2018. But Russia might still have a card up its sleeve. Cartoon by Joe Heller.
Possible Reason Asuka Started Using The Arm Bar Finish -World News
Possible Reason Asuka Started Using The Arm Bar Finish 10 days ago
According to The Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Asuka switching to an arm bar finish instead of the Asuka lock may be leading to a major match[.........] The post Possible Reason Asuka Started Using The Arm Bar Finish appeared first on 411MANIA.
Anthem Gives Ed Nordholm Directive Get Impact to a ‘Break Even’ Point -World News
Anthem Gives Ed Nordholm Directive Get Impact to a ‘Break Even’ Point 10 days ago
Following reports that Impact Wrestling was having financial issues (even noted by former employee Earl Hebner), The Wrestling Observer Newsletter reports that that Anthem has[.........] The post Anthem Gives Ed Nordholm Directive Get Impact to a ‘Break
This Week’s Top 10 Most Watched Shows on The WWE Network -World News
This Week’s Top 10 Most Watched Shows on The WWE Network 10 days ago
According to The Wrestling Observer Newsletter, here are the top 10 most watched shows on the WWE Network (via VOD) for the week… 1. NXT[.........] The post This Week’s Top 10 Most Watched Shows on The WWE Network appeared first on 411MANIA.
The Moneyist: This is what happens when you lend money to a relative (hint: it doesn’t end well) -World News
The Moneyist: This is what happens when you lend money to a relative (hint: it doesn’t end well) 10 days ago
‘My dad lent his brother $20,000 and hasn’t seen one red cent since.’
WWE Fans Can Now ‘Walk The Aisle,’ Drew McIntyre Works Out After Surgery -World News
WWE Fans Can Now ‘Walk The Aisle,’ Drew McIntyre Works Out After Surgery 10 days ago
WWE has provided fans with an opportunity to 'Walk the Aisle' at upcoming live events, whilst former NXT Champion, Drew McIntyre is back in the gym.
Rockstar Spud Teases NXT Debut, Is He The ‘Ominous Force?’, Young Bucks Tweet Adam Cole -World News
Rockstar Spud Teases NXT Debut, Is He The ‘Ominous Force?’, Young Bucks Tweet Adam Cole 10 days ago
Rockstar Spud has teased that he is the 'ominous presence' that is coming to NXT in the near future, whilst the Young Bucks tweeted Adam Cole.