Is LeBron, Harden, Curry or Kyrie on the best MVP path? -

Is LeBron, Harden, Curry or Kyrie on the best MVP path?

Credit: espn.com

  • Nov 30 2017 13:55About: 12 days ago
  • 10 views

Who has the clearest path to MVP as we reach the quarter point of the NBA season?

Having led his Houston Rockets to the Western Conference's best record at 16-4, James Harden -- the runner-up to Russell Westbrook a season ago -- looks like the early MVP favorite. However, four-time MVP LeBron James is also in the mix to reclaim the award he last won in 2012-13, and other contenders could emerge.

Using the historical breakdown I put together last fall, let's take a look at which paths this season's candidates could follow to winning MVP.


Best player on best team

MVP percentage: 91.7 percent (11 of 12)

I'm defining the best player as the one with the most wins above replacement player (WARP) by my metric. When that player has also led his team to the league's best record, it basically has been a wrap for MVP. Only Karl Malone, who was beat by Michael Jordan in 1997-98, has failed to win MVP when meeting these criteria since media began voting for the award in 1980-81.

There appear to be two realistic candidates to join this group. One is Harden, whose Rockets have the second-best projection in both FiveThirtyEight's CARM-Elo model and ESPN's Basketball Power Index. The other is Stephen Curry. Remember him? The two-time MVP is putting up numbers in the same ballpark as those that won the 2014-15 award for him, despite making only 37 percent of his 3-point attempts.

If Curry could maintain something close to the incredible 58 percent of his shots he's making inside the arc while returning to his usual 3-point accuracy, that could make him the league's most valuable player by advanced stats despite his limited minutes (32.3 per game so far). Already, Curry is second behind Harden in ESPN's real plus-minus (RPM).


Top-5 player on best team

MVP percentage: 66.7 percent (10 of 15)

It's more realistic for Curry to land in this category, which has produced MVPs more often than not. He's currently sixth in WARP but tied for fourth in player win percentage, the per-minute component of WARP akin to PER. The question then is how much Curry would be hampered in the voting by playing with multiple other stars, most notably Kevin Durant -- still often considered the better of the Golden State Warriors' two MVPs.

I don't think Curry is anywhere near a favorite for MVP, but given the probability the Warriors end up with the league's best record and the possibility he plays even better going forward, his chances are probably underrated.


Best player on top-10/top-5 team

MVP percentage (top 10, but outside top 5): 42.9 percent (3 of 7)

MVP percentage (top 5): 30.8 percent (4 of 13)

We'll lump these two categories together since there's no compelling reason to believe the leader in WARP actually has a better chance of winning MVP when his team finishes with a top-10 record but outside the top five. While leading the league in WARP hardly guarantees an MVP, it puts a player in the conversation as long as their team is competitive.

The two players with the best chance of qualifying for one of these categories are Harden and James, the latter of whom holds a slight lead in both WARP and Basketball-Reference.com's value over replacement player (VORP) metric. After a slow start, the Cleveland Cavaliers again look likely to finish with a top-five record (FiveThirtyEight has them tied for the fourth-best projection, while they're tied for fifth in BPI, and neither system knows specifically that Isaiah Thomas could return before long).

So if James can keep this up, this looks like his best shot at MVP since his Miami Heat days. After all, as Brian Windhorst noted before the season, research by our former colleague Tom Haberstroh found that James has typically played at an MVP level in the second half of recent campaigns.

As for Harden, the big question -- explored earlier this week by Neil Paine of FiveThirtyEight -- is whether he can continue to produce at such a high level while playing with Chris Paul. Inevitably, Harden's volume will take some hit playing with another elite playmaker, and we'll see whether his efficiency can rise enough to compensate.


Top-5 player on top-5 team

MVP percentage: 8.1 percent (5 of 62)

The huge drop in MVP chances from the last tier emphasizes how important it is to either be the league's best player statistically or play on the team with the league's best record. Both players who qualified for this category last season (Harden and James, with Kawhi Leonard just missing out in WARP) lost out to WARP leader Westbrook despite the Oklahoma City Thunder's weaker record.


Top-20/top-10 player on best team

MVP percentage (top 20, but outside top 10): 5.6 percent (1 of 18)

MVP percentage (top 10): 5.0 percent (1 of 20)

Historically, MVP voters have occasionally rewarded the top player on the team with the league's best record with MVP even when he doesn't rate as exceptionally valuable in terms of WARP. That's the path for Kyrie Irving, an MVP candidate at this point largely because his Boston Celtics have the NBA's best record at 18-4.

Irving's box-score stats are largely similar to what he posted last season with the Cleveland Cavaliers, when he wasn't even chosen for an All-NBA team. Because he has improved his effort as part of the league's best defense, Irving has in fact been more valuable this season, and his outstanding clutch play also deserves bonus credit. Still, the only way for Irving to win MVP while ranking ninth in WARP, seventh in VORP and eighth in RPM is the Celtics somehow holding off Golden State and Houston for the NBA's best record.


Top-20 player on top-5 team

MVP percentage: 2.0 percent (2 of 101)

While this category has improbably produced a pair of MVPs (Allen Iverson in 2000-01 and Steve Nash in 2005-06), it's unlikely such a player would win now that there is more focus on advanced stats in the discussion.


Best player on bottom-20 team

MVP percentage: 0.0 percent (0 of 5)

Because the Thunder finished with the NBA's 10th-best record, there still has yet to be an MVP from a team outside the league's top 10 in the modern era. That's bad news for Giannis Antetokounmpo and Anthony Davis, who rank third and fourth respectively in WARP and third and sixth in VORP.

Both Antetokounmpo's Bucks and Davis' Pelicans are projected to finish a little better than .500. Barring their teams making a jump or the kind of history-making season Westbrook had last year, when he averaged a triple-double, that's probably not good enough for them to be serious MVP contenders.



Follow Us on Twitter

race features several players taking various paths award. Kevin Pelton tracks stats trends rate candidates.

Related stories with Is LeBron, Harden, Curry or Kyrie on the best MVP path?

High On Fire complete London’s 2018 Desertfest line-up -World News
High On Fire complete London’s 2018 Desertfest line-up 12 days ago
High On Fire have been announced as the final headliner’s for 2018’s Desertfest in London. The Californian metal band will be celebrating 20 years together at the festival. The annual festival – which will once again be held in Camden for its 2018 e
HDFC MF board gives nod for IPO -World News
HDFC MF board gives nod for IPO 12 days ago
HDFC Asset Management Company (commonly referred as HDFC MF) could soon become the second asset manager to go public. The country's second-largest mutual fund (MF) on Thursday got its board approval to initiate the process to go public. HDFC MF is backed
N.Korea fires missile capable of reaching entire US mainland -World News
N.Korea fires missile capable of reaching entire US mainland 12 days ago
North Korea successfully test fired a newly developed Intercontinental Ballistic Missile (ICBM) early Wednesday morning, Pyongyang's state news agency reported.
TAE fusion venture wins supercomputer time — and reports progress on test device -World News
TAE fusion venture wins supercomputer time — and reports progress on test device 12 days ago
TAE Technologies, the venture formerly known as Tri Alpha Energy, says it’s been admitted into a U.S. Department of Energy supercomputer program that should accelerate its drive to harness nuclear fusion. The Office of Science program — known as
Tata Nexon Has Crossed 10,000 Production Milestone In India -World News
Tata Nexon Has Crossed 10,000 Production Milestone In India 12 days ago
Tata Motors has rolled out the 10,000th Nexon subcompact SUV in India in two months. The Maruti Suzuki Vitara Brezza and Ford EcoSport rival was launched in India in September 2017.
Mahindra And Renesas Announce Technical Partnership For Formula E -World News
Mahindra And Renesas Announce Technical Partnership For Formula E 12 days ago
Mahindra and Mahindra has announced a strategic partnership for Formula E with Japan's Reneses Electronics Corporation. Reneses is a supplier of advanced semi-conductor solutions will come on-board as...
Moment angry father confronted man who tried to groom his daughter -World News
Moment angry father confronted man who tried to groom his daughter 12 days ago
He has been jailed for three years.
Matt Lauer on Sexual Misconduct Allegations: 'I Am Truly Sorry' -World News
Matt Lauer on Sexual Misconduct Allegations: 'I Am Truly Sorry' 12 days ago
Matt Lauer addressed sexual misconduct allegations in a contrite statement on Thursday.
Off-White™ x Champion Is Now Available Online -World News
Off-White™ x Champion Is Now Available Online 12 days ago
Having now been teased for several months, Off-White™'s collaboration with Champion is now officially available for purchase. The 16-piece capsule collection consists of hoodies, sweatshirts, T-shirts, track pants and shorts, each of them utilizing so
West Africa population planners battle to woo Muslim hearts -World News
West Africa population planners battle to woo Muslim hearts 12 days ago
DAKAR/LIBORE, Niger: Mabingue Ngom, the head of the U.N. Population Fund in West Africa, knows that if he wants to cut birth rates he can't ignore religion. Population experts like Ngom are worried that if West Africa's population continues to grow at it
Trump says China's special envoy appeared to have 'no impact' on N.K.
 -World News
Trump says China's special envoy appeared to have 'no impact' on N.K. 12 days ago
U.S. President Donald Trump said Thursday that China's special envoy to North Korea appears to have had "no impact" on reining in North Korea after the country fired a new long-range missile a day earlier.
Irish PM names Foreign Minister Simon Coveney as deputy PM -World News
Irish PM names Foreign Minister Simon Coveney as deputy PM 12 days ago
Irish Prime Minister Leo Varadkar on Thursday named Foreign Minister Simon Coveney as deputy prime minister, replacing Frances Fitzgerald, whose resignation over a policing scandal on Tuesday allowed the government to avoid a snap election.