UPDATE 1-India's case against Mallya politically motivated, UK court hears -

UPDATE 1-India's case against Mallya politically motivated, UK court hears

Credit: reuters.com

  • Dec 05 2017 16:55About: 12 days ago
  • 10 views

LONDON (Reuters) - The Indian government’s fraud case against tycoon Vijay Mallya is baseless and politically motivated, his defense lawyer told a London court on Tuesday as she battled to prevent his extradition to his home country.


Vijay Mallya arrives at Westminster Magistrates Court in London, Britain, December 4, 2017. REUTERS/Simon Dawson

Mallya, who lives in Britain, stands accused in India of fraudulently palming off losses from his now defunct Kingfisher Airlines onto banks by taking out loans he had no intention of repaying.


His defense team argue that he is being used as a scapegoat by Indian politicians of all stripes to deflect public anger at the accumulation of bad debts by state-owned banks.


The 61-year-old, nicknamed “the King of Good Times” after the slogan on bottles of one of his premium beers and his hard partying lifestyle, had business interests ranging from aviation to liquor.


He is also the co-owner of Formula One motor racing team Force India.


The case against him centers on a series of loans Kingfisher obtained from Indian banks, especially state-owned lender IDBI. The banks want to recover a total of about $1.4 billion that the state says the defunct airline owes.


Mallya’s British defense lawyer, Clare Montgomery, told Westminster Magistrates Court that India had made a series of serious allegations against him and others that did not have “a shred of evidence” to back them up.


She also said that the Indian government’s case revealed a “shocking” lack of appreciation of how companies function and of basic realities such as the effects of incorporation and the rights of shareholders.


“Economically and legally, it is impossible to palm off losses onto banks by borrowing to pass on the cost of failure,” she said.


Vijay Mallya arrives at Westminster Magistrates Court in London, Britain, December 4, 2017. REUTERS/Simon Dawson

Montgomery said she would call witnesses later in the two-week hearing to give evidence on what she called the “political ramifications” of the case.


She accused several Indian parties including the ruling BJP of “making political capital from the Mallya case on the assumption there was a fraud”.


Montgomery said India’s Central Bureau of Investigation, which is prosecuting the case, had a “long and inglorious history of being politically motivated in the cases it brings”.


She also criticized prison conditions in India, saying that they were worse than in Russia, a country to which British courts have on several occasions refused to extradite suspects for that reason.


Montgomery said there were competing narratives, fraud versus business failure, and that no reasonable jury would be able to reach a safe conclusion that there had been a deliberate intent to defraud.


Mallya, the focus of intense media interest in India, arrived wearing a dark suit and yellow tie and was mobbed by cameramen as he walked into the building.


Inside the courtroom he spoke only to confirm his name and age, before sitting quietly in the glass-walled dock as Montgomery spoke.


She said that the government’s allegation that Mallya had deliberately misled banks by overstating Kingfisher’s projected profits was “a false premise”.


That was because airlines were subject to many unpredictable factors beyond their control, such as fuel cost fluctuations and the global economic climate, so to make entirely accurate projections several years in advance was unrealistic.


The judge, England’s Chief Magistrate Emma Arbuthnot, will have to decide whether there is a prima facie case against Mallya and whether the alleged crimes would be offences in Britain as well as India.






Follow Us on Twitter

Indian government’s fraud case against tycoon Vijay Mallya baseless politically motivated defense lawyer told London court Tuesday battled prevent extradition home country.

Related stories with UPDATE 1-India's case against Mallya politically motivated, UK court hears

Dalits protest in Delhi against NSA slapped on Bhim army leader -World News
Dalits protest in Delhi against NSA slapped on Bhim army leader 12 days ago
NEW DELHI: Dalit leaders from 17 states who gathered here on Tuesday to stage a protest against the atrocities on them and to demand the withdrawal of National Security Act (NSA) slapped on Bhim Army chief Chandra Shekhar and two other community lead
France advised against Sanofi's dengue drug for its territories -World News
France advised against Sanofi's dengue drug for its territories 12 days ago
PARIS: A public body close to France's health ministry last year advised against the use of a dengue vaccine in the country's overseas territories that is currently at the centre of a health scare, regulatory documents show. Concerns surrounding the vacc
LIVE UPDATES: Blood found in apartment matched DNA of off-duty cop, murder trial hears -World News
LIVE UPDATES: Blood found in apartment matched DNA of off-duty cop, murder trial hears 12 days ago
A jury has heard Catherine Campbell's blood was found inside the Halifax apartment where the off-duty police officer was allegedly murdered.
Businessman accused of bilking Filipino workers pleads guilty in Halifax court -World News
Businessman accused of bilking Filipino workers pleads guilty in Halifax court 12 days ago
He allegedly counselled the workers to lie about their wages if they wanted to stay in Canada - with some working for as low as $3.13 per hour.
Arvin Golic to be sentenced for manslaughter in death of Luka Gordic -World News
Arvin Golic to be sentenced for manslaughter in death of Luka Gordic 12 days ago
Arvin Golic is set to be sentenced today in the stabbing death of Luka Gordic.
WWE News: Preview Video For Tonight’s WWE Smackdown, Updates on TJP & Lince Dorado, Roman Reigns on Why The Shield Works -World News
WWE News: Preview Video For Tonight’s WWE Smackdown, Updates on TJP & Lince Dorado, Roman Reigns on Why The Shield Works 12 days ago
– Here is a new video, where Cathy Kelly breaks down 7 things you need to know before tonight’s SmackDown… – 205 live roster members[.........] The post WWE News: Preview Video For Tonight’s WWE Smackdown, Updates on TJP & Lince
252bhp Vauxhall Insignia GSi priced from £33,375 in the UK -World News
252bhp Vauxhall Insignia GSi priced from £33,375 in the UK 12 days ago
The car is powered by a 2.0-litre four-cylinder turbocharged petrol that outputs 295lb ft and is...
Machine Gun Kelly – Kevin Owens Tease, Update on Pontiac Silverdome, Seven Things to Know Before Smackdown (Video) -World News
Machine Gun Kelly – Kevin Owens Tease, Update on Pontiac Silverdome, Seven Things to Know Before Smackdown (Video) 12 days ago
Machine Gun Kelly - Kevin Owens Tease, Update on Pontiac Silverdome Implosion, Seven Things to Know Before Smackdown (Video)!
2017 Subaru Legacy Sport Long-Term Update 4: Driving With AWD and Using the Nav System -World News
2017 Subaru Legacy Sport Long-Term Update 4: Driving With AWD and Using the Nav System 12 days ago
Some readers had a couple questions about Subaru Legacy’s all-wheel-drive system. @MT_Royer do you notice any difference between legacy's AWD manners vs. standard FWD fam sedan? — Backroad Maverick (@BackroadMav) June 12, 2017 You should trade
Chris Pratt Gives Status Update on His Facebook Impostor, Shuns Online Dating -World News
Chris Pratt Gives Status Update on His Facebook Impostor, Shuns Online Dating 12 days ago
Chris Pratt, who just filed for divorce, will not join the hoards on online dating services.
Supporters free ex-Georgian leader Saakashvili from Ukrainian police amid chaotic scenes -World News
Supporters free ex-Georgian leader Saakashvili from Ukrainian police amid chaotic scenes 12 days ago
KIEV (Reuters) - Ukrainian supporters of former Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili freed him from a police van on Tuesday after his detention on suspicion of assisting a criminal organisation sparked clashes with police in central Kiev.
‘One of the greatest shorting opportunities ever’: Hedge funds ready to bet against Bitcoin -World News
‘One of the greatest shorting opportunities ever’: Hedge funds ready to bet against Bitcoin 12 days ago
Hedge funds, which have largely stayed on the sidelines, are waiting for the Chicago Mercantile Exchange's futures market to open to bet against the cryptocurrency