“No evidence” to justify extraditing Mallya to India, UK court hears -

“No evidence” to justify extraditing Mallya to India, UK court hears

Credit: reuters.com

  • Dec 05 2017 12:55About: 6 days ago
  • 6 views

LONDON (Reuters) - Indian tycoon Vijay Mallya should not be extradited to his home country to face fraud charges related to the collapse of his Kingfisher Airlines because there is no evidence to back up India’s case against him, a London court heard on Tuesday. 


Vijay Mallya arrives at Westminster Magistrates Court in London, Britain, December 4, 2017. REUTERS/Simon Dawson

    The Indian government has requested Mallya’s extradition from Britain accusing him of fraudulently palming off the airline’s losses onto banks by taking out loans he had no intention of repaying.


    The 61-year-old has had business interests ranging from aviation to liquor. He is also the co-owner of Formula One motor racing team Force India. 


    The case against him centers on a series of loans Kingfisher obtained from Indian banks, especially state-owned lender IDBI. The banks want to recover a total of about $1.4 billion that the state says the defunct airline owes. 


    “There is no evidence,” Mallya’s defense lawyer Clare Montgomery told Westminster Magistrates Court. 


    “Economically and legally it is impossible to palm off losses onto banks by borrowing to pass on the cost of failure.”


    She said there were competing narratives, fraud versus business failure, and that no reasonable jury would be able to reach a safe conclusion that there had been a deliberate intent to defraud.


    She added that the Indian government’s case revealed a “shocking” lack of appreciation of how companies function and of basic realities such as the effects of incorporation and the rights of shareholders. 


Vijay Mallya arrives at Westminster Magistrates Court in London, Britain, December 4, 2017. REUTERS/Simon Dawson

    Mallya, the focus of intense media interest in India, arrived wearing a dark suit and yellow tie and was mobbed by cameramen as he walked into the building. 


    Inside the courtroom he spoke only to confirm his name and age, before sitting quietly in the glass-walled dock as Montgomery spoke. 


    She said the government’s allegation that Mallya had deliberately misled banks by overstating Kingfisher’s projected profits was “a false premise”. 


    That was because airlines were subject to many unpredictable factors beyond their control, such as fuel cost fluctuations and the global economic climate, so to make entirely accurate projections several years in advance was unrealistic. 


    Montgomery also rejected the allegation that senior managers at state-owned lender IDBI were involved in Mallya’s fraudulent plan. 


    “That is one of a number of allegations that prosecuting authorities have made without a shred of evidence,” she said. 


    Montgomery also rejected the allegation that Mallya had improperly spent the money borrowed from the banks, saying there was no evidence of disbursements on anything other than the benefit of Kingfisher. 


    The extradition hearing is expected to last two weeks. The judge, England’s Chief Magistrate Emma Arbuthnot, will have to decide whether there is a prima facie case against Mallya and whether the alleged crimes would be offences in Britain as well as India. 






Follow Us on Twitter

Indian tycoon Vijay Mallya should extradited home country face fraud charges related collapse Kingfisher Airlines because there evidence back India’s case against him London court heard Tuesday. 

Related stories with “No evidence” to justify extraditing Mallya to India, UK court hears

EU needs to project its power in Trump era in order to survive, says German Foreign Minister -World News
EU needs to project its power in Trump era in order to survive, says German Foreign Minister 6 days ago
Germany's foreign minister on Tuesday urged Europe to define and defend its own interests, warning that Washington's retreat from the world stage may continue even after Donald Trump's presidency.
Motorcycling-Malaysia wins MotoGP's best Grand Prix of 2017 -World News
Motorcycling-Malaysia wins MotoGP's best Grand Prix of 2017 6 days ago
Malaysia's motorcycle Grand Prix was named by the sport's governing body on Tuesday as the best race of the 2017 MotoGP championship.
Bengals move into top 10 (in 2018 NFL Draft order) -World News
Bengals move into top 10 (in 2018 NFL Draft order) 6 days ago
The Bengals lost last night, but moved up a few spots in the draft order, which is all the consolation you get this time of year when you’re not in the playoff mix. Of course, the Browns (0-12) would still pick first in the 2018 NFL Draft if the sea
Todd Bowles: Disciplined players lost trust, have to earn it back -World News
Todd Bowles: Disciplined players lost trust, have to earn it back 6 days ago
The Jets had a surprise on their inactive list for last Sunday’s game against the Chiefs when starting linebacker Darron Lee was left out of the lineup for the first time this season. Lee confirmed his change in role was due to a violation of team r
3rd Test, Day 4: Shami, Jadeja leave Sri Lanka with plenty to do on final day -World News
3rd Test, Day 4: Shami, Jadeja leave Sri Lanka with plenty to do on final day 6 days ago
Mohammed Shami (1/8) and Ravindra Jadeja (2/5) left Sri Lanka reeling at 31/3 at stumps on Day 3 of the Kotla Test. Can the islanders survive the final day of the series? Or will India win another Test match?
New Indian envoy presents his credentials to Xi Jinping -World News
New Indian envoy presents his credentials to Xi Jinping 6 days ago
Xi received the credentials of Bambawale, and 10 other envoys, at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing, the state-run Xinhua news agency reported.
The Way Back Home give a Feeling of Satiety to us -World News
The Way Back Home give a Feeling of Satiety to us 6 days ago
  The Way Back Home give a Feeling of Satiety to us   The world is so beautiful and we would like out of curiosity to discover
PM Najib wants Umno to resolve internal tensions to ensure smooth general election -World News
PM Najib wants Umno to resolve internal tensions to ensure smooth general election 6 days ago
December 05, 2017 8:43 PMKuala Lumpur - Malaysia's long-ruling Umno party must place victory in a looming general election ahead of personal ambitions, and resolve its internal tensions "like a family", Prime Minister Najib Razak told his party chiefs yes
US investors overweight in stocks despite market fears: study -World News
US investors overweight in stocks despite market fears: study 6 days ago
Three out of four U.S. investors age 40 and older worry about a correction that will eventually end the long-running bull market in stocks, yet most refuse to head for the exits.
UK's Cineworld targets US expansion with US$3.6 billion deal to buy Regal Entertainment -World News
UK's Cineworld targets US expansion with US$3.6 billion deal to buy Regal Entertainment 6 days ago
Britain's Cineworld Group Plc sealed an agreement to buy larger U.S. peer Regal Entertainment Group on Tuesday for US$3.6 billion in cash, a deal that would create the world's second largest movie theatre operator.
Toyota: Road car styled LMP1 plan will brings manufacturers to WEC -World News
Toyota: Road car styled LMP1 plan will brings manufacturers to WEC 6 days ago
Toyota says proposals to make future LMP1 cars look more like high-performance road cars have generated "a lot of interest" in the World Endurance Championship's top class among manufacturers
Court rules against injured vets in fight for pensions -World News
Court rules against injured vets in fight for pensions 6 days ago
The B.C. Court of Appeal has dealt a devastating blow to a group of injured veterans engaged in a landmark legal battle with the federal government.