The Price of War With North Korea -

The Price of War With North Korea

Credit: nytimes.com

  • Dec 06 2017 11:35About: 6 days ago
  • 8 views


During his first official trip to Asia last month, President Trump issued a stern warning to North Korea: “Do not underestimate us. And do not try us.” But for his part, Mr. Trump should not underestimate the steep human cost of initiating a war against Pyongyang.

The key problem for the United States is the likely possibility that North Korea has the missiles to deliver nuclear bombs to South Korea and Japan. If one of these weapons were to reach its target, an entire city would be annihilated.

And even if an American first strike knocked out North Korea’s nuclear capacity, millions of South Korean civilians, and American and South Korean soldiers, would be vulnerable to retaliation with conventional or chemical weapons. Pyongyang could devastate Seoul and kill tens of thousands of people.

North Korea may have as many as 250 mobile missile launchers, some of which could fire nuclear-tipped missiles. If some of these mobile units were dispersed at the time of an American attack, it’s unlikely that the United States could destroy all of them before one fires a missile. America has not had much success in finding and destroying mobile missile launchers in recent wars.


An American attack that truly caught North Korea by surprise could minimize the effectiveness of a North Korean counterattack — but not eliminate the possibility. And surprise would be difficult, if not impossible, to achieve.













North Korea probably has reliable intelligence sources reporting on activity in South Korea and Japan that could warn of an attack. And news reports from the United States and elsewhere, or the intelligence agencies of other countries like China and Russia, could also warn Pyongyang.

To plan a surprise, the United States would have to make as few visible preparations as possible. Washington could not significantly increase its forces in the region without raising alarms in the North. The South Koreans would have to be kept in the dark, and they could make no preparations for war. Nor could American civilians be alerted and evacuated from South Korea. Any preparations would have to be masked behind other more normal activities such as training exercises.



But the surprise attack would still require large numbers of powerful, precise, concrete-piercing munitions to destroy the hardened bases that store North Korean missiles and nuclear warheads. Only American strategic bombers — B-2s and B-1Bs, which take hours to reach North Korea from Guam, or longer from bases in the United States — could do this job. And the bombers would require considerable support from aerial tankers.

It is difficult to estimate how many bombers it would take because there is little public information about North Korean military bases. My own estimate, based on marrying published estimates of the number of North Korean missile launchers to past American practice in deploying such systems, is that an initial attack could require at least two dozen bombers, capable of carrying nearly 500 one-ton precision guided bombs, or smaller numbers of larger weapons.

American submarines could move close enough to the North Korean coastline to launch cruise missiles while the bombers are en route. This would minimize the chance that North Korea’s mobile weapons are moved before the bombers arrive and would suppress some of the North Korean air-defense weapons.

But the overall effort would be so large that trying to catch the North Koreans by surprise would be a high-risk gamble. And the first wave of American assaults would have to be focused on attacking nuclear infrastructure, at the expense of dismantling conventional weapons.

Thus, even if an American attack on the North’s nuclear weapons were entirely successful, North Korea would have the opportunity to retaliate with conventional forces against unprepared soldiers and civilians in South Korea. In most scenarios, it is all but inevitable that many thousands of civilians, and American and South Korean soldiers, would die.


A surprise American nuclear attack would offer the greatest chance of eliminating the North Korean nuclear arsenal and of preventing a conventional counterattack. America’s nuclear weapons are quite accurate and always ready for action.

But the detonation of even a small number of nuclear weapons in North Korea would produce hellish results. The United States would make itself an international pariah for decades, if not centuries. It is entirely possible that the American military personnel would even resist the order to execute such an attack. For strategic, humanitarian and constitutional reasons, a first-strike nuclear option should not even be on the table (other than to forestall an imminent nuclear attack from North Korea).

The complexity, risks and costs of a military strike against North Korea are too high. A combination of diplomacy and deterrence, based on the already impressive strength of South Korean and United States conventional and nuclear forces, is a wise alternative.










Follow Us on Twitter

inevitable that many thousands South Koreans Americans would sacrificed.

Related stories with The Price of War With North Korea

South Korean leader Moon Jae-in to visit China next week for talks on North Korea -World News
South Korean leader Moon Jae-in to visit China next week for talks on North Korea 6 days ago
South Korean President Moon Jae-in will visit China next week for talks on North Korea and other issues, his office said on Wednesday, amid tentative signs of diplomatic movement after months of high tensions over Pyongyang’s nuclear and missile thr
State-owned Chinese newspaper on border with North Korea tells readers how to prepare for nuclear disaster -World News
State-owned Chinese newspaper on border with North Korea tells readers how to prepare for nuclear disaster 6 days ago
A state-run newspaper in northeast China published a full-page article advising local residents on how to cope with a nuclear attack – a sign of Beijing’s concern about a possible disaster in the Korean peninsula. Wednesday’s article in
Life is Strange: Before the Storm's final episode has a release date -World News
Life is Strange: Before the Storm's final episode has a release date 6 days ago
The third and final episode of Life is Strange: Before the Storm will launch just before Christmas, on 20th December (thanks, IGN).Titled 'Hell is Empty', the episode will round out the three-part storyline set a couple of years before the original Life i
Capcom made an official Amaterasu Courier for Dota 2 and it looks awesome -World News
Capcom made an official Amaterasu Courier for Dota 2 and it looks awesome 6 days ago
Capcom has submitted an Amaterasu Courier for use in Dota 2 - and it looks like it will be added to the game.Amaterasu, protagonist of Capcom's lovely Okami series, is currently up for votes on the Steam Workshop. The reception has been positive, so it lo
Arms' next Party Crash poses the ultimate question -World News
Arms' next Party Crash poses the ultimate question 6 days ago
Are you a scrub or are you a saint? That is, in essence, the question being posed by Arms' next Party Crash, it's time-limited event that sees players fight for two characters as they partake in a quick succession of themed fights over a couple of days. I
Closing arguments continue at trial of 2 men accused of killing Laura Babcock -World News
Closing arguments continue at trial of 2 men accused of killing Laura Babcock 6 days ago
The Crown alleges Millard and Smich killed Babcock on July 3 or 4, 2012, because she was the odd woman out in a love triangle with Millard and his girlfriend.
North End stabbing leaves one man in hospital -World News
North End stabbing leaves one man in hospital 6 days ago
A Tuesday night assault with a knife has left a 30-year-old man in hospital.
Hong Kong’s first postmortems for pets on offer at new City University laboratory -World News
Hong Kong’s first postmortems for pets on offer at new City University laboratory 6 days ago
A Hong Kong university is set to offer the city’s first commercial postmortems for pets through a new veterinary diagnostic laboratory. The City University facility has hired three veterinary pathologists to carry out the examinations and to provide
Sharp increase in number of false allegations against Hong Kong police officers -World News
Sharp increase in number of false allegations against Hong Kong police officers 6 days ago
The police’s complaints system has been abused as a defence in court, with the number of false allegations against officers recording a sharp 43 per cent increase between 2016 and 2017, the police watchdog said on Wednesday. The Independent Police C
The Crown season 2: Who was Christine Keeler? Who was the woman in the Profumo Affair? -World News
The Crown season 2: Who was Christine Keeler? Who was the woman in the Profumo Affair? 6 days ago
THE CROWN season 2 is set to look at the explosive Profumo Affair when it hits Netflix later this week. But who was Christine Keeler, the woman at the centre of the scandal?
Dancing on Ice 2018: ITV REPLACES Monty Panesar with THIS singing star due to nasty injury -World News
Dancing on Ice 2018: ITV REPLACES Monty Panesar with THIS singing star due to nasty injury 6 days ago
DANCING ON ICE bosses have been forced to find a replacement after Monty Pansear had to withdraw due to a broken ankle.
Game of Thrones season 8 DELAY: Iain Glenn reveals THIS is why series will return in 2019 -World News
Game of Thrones season 8 DELAY: Iain Glenn reveals THIS is why series will return in 2019 6 days ago
GAME OF THRONES fans were left devastated when they learned that they may have to wait until 2019 for the final season of the HBO series to air.