What've we come to: Bombay HC on Padmavati row -

What've we come to: Bombay HC on Padmavati row

Credit: timesofindia.indiatimes.com

  • Dec 07 2017 20:45About: 8 days ago
  • 10 views



MUMBAI: The Bombay high court on Thursday asked where the country was headed while alluding to "open threats" made to stall the release of the film Padmavati and the announcement of a reward to "kill" its lead actress Deepika Padukone.



"In which other country do you see threats made to artistes and performers? It is distressing to know a person makes a feature film and several others work tirelessly towards it but are unable to release the film for public viewing because of continuous threats... A feature film cannot be released in this country. What have we come to?" asked a bench of Justices S C Dharmadhikari and Bharati Dangre.



While pointing out that threats are being issued openly and shown on television, the judges said people are taking pride in announcing rewards for killing artistes and performers. "Today somebody says, 'I will give a reward if you get a performer, artiste, actress killed'... Even chief ministers are saying they will not allow release of the film in their states," said Justice Dharmadhikari, adding, "This is censorship of a different kind. If this is happening to people with financial strength and backing, what about poor people?"



The court's remarks were made while it rapped CBI and state CID for their failure to trace the absconding killers of rationalists Narendra Dabholkar and Govind Pansare despite being given time to crack the cases. "The crime is committed in 2013 (Dhabolkar) and 2015 (Pansare) and you are still finding them (the killers)?" asked Justice Dharmadhikari. The court is hearing pleas by their families to monitor investigations into the murders.



"In other parts of the world, a truck with weapons drives into people. In less than 24 hours, the person is caught dead or alive, identified, a role is attributed and the whole country is alerted. They take it as an affront to the nation. We have not learned anything from the attack on the Parliament and on a prime minister," the judge added. PM Indira Gandhi was assassinated in 1984.



While Anil Singh, additional solicitor general for CBI, said "sincere efforts are being made", senior advocate Ashok Mundargi for the state CID assured the court that the probe was on the right track. "We have not made success but have not given up," Mundargi added.



The judges, though, said they would not allow the matter to linger for years. "In this country, do you want a situation where people cannot voice their opinion? We can't allow constitutional rights to be taken away like this. Every time a person says he or she wants to voice their opinion, somebody says 'I won't allow it'," said Justice Dharmadhikari. The judges questioned whether any senior officer of the agencies had bothered to find out why the probe has made no headway and if it is being scuttled.



The judges said those who "openly and boldly" voice their opinion are being targeted by "people who won't like their opinion" and threatened with elimination by fringe groups. "That is what is disturbing us. We have been noticing that at the core of all these crimes is the bold attempt being made by fringe groups to attack those who voice their rational thoughts, feelings and expressions," they added.



The court said the country cuts a "sorry figure" with bold threats and attacks on people voicing their opinion. "We cannot take pride in being the largest democracy in the world when we are repeatedly confronted with incidents and happenings day in and day out," said Justice Dharmadhikari.



The judges said it is time superiors of both agencies "guiding and directing the investigation should take the lead and take stock of the situation". Assured by Singh and Mundargi that a meeting would be convened with the secretary (home), DGP, and joint director, CBI , the court deferred summoning them and posted the hearing on December 21 for an update.







Follow Us on Twitter

Bombay high court Thursday asked where country headed while alluding “open threats” made stall release film Padmavati announcement reward “kill” lead actress Deepika Padukone.

Related stories with What've we come to: Bombay HC on Padmavati row

Legal Marijuana Sales to Hit $10 Billion USD for the Year -World News
Legal Marijuana Sales to Hit $10 Billion USD for the Year 8 days ago
The legal cannabis market continues to flourish as news has surfaced that its retail sales have surpassed what experts predicted. According to Arcview Market Research, the sale of legal marijuana is expected to have a 33% increase over last year's numbers
Parley x adidas UltraBOOST Mid Collaboration First Look -World News
Parley x adidas UltraBOOST Mid Collaboration First Look 8 days ago
Releasing an alternative take to the Uncaged silhouette, adidas and Parley have teamed up again on a pair of sustainably built men's running shoes -- this time in the form of a mid-cut UltraBOOST design. Signature wavy blue lines dot the heel counter whic
Russia says Pyongyang wants direct talks with Washington: Agencies -World News
Russia says Pyongyang wants direct talks with Washington: Agencies 8 days ago
December 08, 2017 4:09 AMMOSCOW (REUTERS) - Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said on Thursday (Dec 7) that North Korea wants direct talks with the United States to seek guarantees on its security from Washington, Russian news agencies reported.
Netflix Strikes Unique Deal for Alex Garland's 'Annihilation' Adaptation -World News
Netflix Strikes Unique Deal for Alex Garland's 'Annihilation' Adaptation 8 days ago
Netflix has struck a groundbreaking deal with Paramount Pictures and Skydance to receive the international rights to the Alex Garland sci-fi thriller Annihilation. The terms of the partnership will allow Netflix to bring Annihilation to its overseas strea
Enter to Win a Pair of adidas YEEZY Powerphase Grey -World News
Enter to Win a Pair of adidas YEEZY Powerphase Grey 8 days ago
adidas Originals and Kanye West recently revealed the official store list for the anticipated YEEZY Powerphase wrapped in a subdued monochromatic “Grey” colorway. Ahead of its release on December 9 is a new HBX raffle for the low-tops. To win a pair (
Square-Enix RPG Lost Sphear Demo Now Available On Switch, PlayStation 4, And PC -World News
Square-Enix RPG Lost Sphear Demo Now Available On Switch, PlayStation 4, And PC 8 days ago
Lost Sphear, the newest RPG from Square-Enix, has a demo available on the Switch, PS4, and Steam today. The game comes from the studio that brought you I Am Setsuna, known as Tokyo RPG Factory, and has a stated goal of creating RPGs that invoke old-schoo
The Bentley GT3 Edition Continental Brings Luxury Touring Back -World News
The Bentley GT3 Edition Continental Brings Luxury Touring Back 8 days ago
Bentley has always been known for style and luxury. The GT3 Edition Continental delivers on this tradition with many options that make this car almost completely customizable. But it’s the performance that will really attract your eye. The new Continent
Consider allowing a Parsi woman to attend father's last rites, Supreme Court asks Parsi body -World News
Consider allowing a Parsi woman to attend father's last rites, Supreme Court asks Parsi body 8 days ago
A Parsi woman had sought a declaration from the court that she would not be barred from attending the funeral of her father merely because she has married outside the religion.
Gujarat polls: High Court stays Election Commission instruction on appointment of polling agents -World News
Gujarat polls: High Court stays Election Commission instruction on appointment of polling agents 8 days ago
The directive was that the polling agents appointed by the should be residents of the area covered under the polling booth concerned or neighbouring booths.
Rahul Gandhi asked party men not to use uncouth language for PM: Congress -World News
Rahul Gandhi asked party men not to use uncouth language for PM: Congress 8 days ago
Aiyar today called Modi a "neech aadmi" (a vile man), who did "dirty politics", kicking up a row on the last day of campaigning for the first phase of the Gujarat Assembly polls.
PM Narendra Modi's wife Jashodaben stresses on
PM Narendra Modi's wife Jashodaben stresses on "Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao" in Uttar Pradesh 8 days ago
The Prime Minister's estranged wife at a mass wedding ceremony urged people to ensure proper education is imparted to the girl-child.