Consider allowing a Parsi woman to attend father's last rites, Supreme Court asks Parsi body -

Consider allowing a Parsi woman to attend father's last rites, Supreme Court asks Parsi body

Credit: newindianexpress.com

  • Dec 07 2017 20:40About: 4 days ago
  • 6 views

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Thursday asked the Parsi Anjuman in Gujarat's Valsad to consider the plea of woman from the community - who has married outside the religion - seeking to attend the funeral of her father as and when he passes away.

Observing that she hasn't "surrendered her affection to father", the five judge constitution bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra asked senior counsel Gopal Subramanium to speak to his client on permitting the petitioner to attend the funeral of her father in Anjuman.

Further observing that "DNA does not evaporates" after marrying outside the religion, the court said that the "marrying under the Special Marriage Act is only for the retention of original identity".

The Parsi woman has sought a declaration from the court that she would not be barred from attending the funeral of her father merely because she has married outside the religion.

Goolrokh M. Gupta, who married outside Parsi religion under the Special Marriage Act, has contended that merely by marrying outside her religion would not result in her excommunication from Parsi religious activities.

She had married a non-Parsi in 1991 and subsequently was denied entry into the Parsi temple of fire or allowed to participate in other rituals. 

Gupta has challenged 2012 Gujarat High Court judgment which says that after marrying a person of another religion under the Special marriage Act, her identity would merge in the identity of her husband.

Besides Goolrokh, her sister Shiraz Rajiv Patodia too has moved the top court challenging the High Court verdict.

Shiraz said that her parents are in their 80s and both sisters wish they live long and healthy, but merely because both siblings had married outside the Parsi religion could not be a ground for not permitting them to attend the last rites in case of an unfortunate situation.

When the court said that if the Anjuman agrees to permit the petitioner to attend her father's funeral, then it would not proceed with the matter as then it would be of academic interest, Indira Jaising told the court that if the Sabrimala matter is referred to the constitution bench, then this too should be heard.

"You can't escape the issue in this case," Jaising told the constitution bench, which said: "Please understand we are not going to shirk our responsibility."

She told the court that in the case before the bench, the petitioners have knocked the doors of the court but there could be thousands of such women whose rights are denied and they are discriminated against.

The court directed the matter's next hearing on December 14.



Follow Us on Twitter

A Parsi woman sought declaration from court that would barred attending funeral father merely because married outside religion.

Related stories with Consider allowing a Parsi woman to attend father's last rites, Supreme Court asks Parsi body

Gujarat polls: High Court stays Election Commission instruction on appointment of polling agents -World News
Gujarat polls: High Court stays Election Commission instruction on appointment of polling agents 4 days ago
The directive was that the polling agents appointed by the should be residents of the area covered under the polling booth concerned or neighbouring booths.
Rahul Gandhi asked party men not to use uncouth language for PM: Congress -World News
Rahul Gandhi asked party men not to use uncouth language for PM: Congress 4 days ago
Aiyar today called Modi a "neech aadmi" (a vile man), who did "dirty politics", kicking up a row on the last day of campaigning for the first phase of the Gujarat Assembly polls.
Punjab and Haryana High Court allows Vikas Barala to take exam under police custody -World News
Punjab and Haryana High Court allows Vikas Barala to take exam under police custody 4 days ago
Haryana BJP chief Subhash Barala's son Vikas Barala was booked on charges of stalking and attempting to abduct a 29-year-old woman, to appear in an examination on December 18 under police custody.
PM Narendra Modi's wife Jashodaben stresses on
PM Narendra Modi's wife Jashodaben stresses on "Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao" in Uttar Pradesh 4 days ago
The Prime Minister's estranged wife at a mass wedding ceremony urged people to ensure proper education is imparted to the girl-child.
Faulty positioning in rugby tackles boosts injury risk -World News
Faulty positioning in rugby tackles boosts injury risk 4 days ago
Head, neck and shoulder injuries during rugby tackles are more common when the tackler’s head is incorrectly positioned in relation to the ball carrier, a small study has found.
White House says it believes Saudi Arabia to allow a Yemeni port to open -World News
White House says it believes Saudi Arabia to allow a Yemeni port to open 4 days ago
WASHINGTON: The White House said on Thursday it had reason to believe that Saudi Arabia would allow a blocked port in Yemen to open. "I believe there are actions that are taking place for a port to open and we'll keep you posted as those details become m
Gujarat polls: Election Commission asks government not to publicise some GST rate cuts till polls are over -World News
Gujarat polls: Election Commission asks government not to publicise some GST rate cuts till polls are over 4 days ago
The EC said it could influence voters in the state where the first phase of elections is on December 9 but has allowed advertisement of simplified tax procedure without mentioning any products.
Morgan Stanley fires former lawmaker for misconduct -World News
Morgan Stanley fires former lawmaker for misconduct 4 days ago
Morgan Stanley has fired former U.S. Democratic lawmaker Harold Ford, Jr., a managing director at the Wall Street bank, for inappropriate conduct, a spokeswoman said on Thursday.
If you don't salute your mother, who would you salute, Afzal Guru: Vice President Venkaiah Naidu -World News
If you don't salute your mother, who would you salute, Afzal Guru: Vice President Venkaiah Naidu 4 days ago
Vande Mataram means praising the mother, he further said while referring to the people who are seeking to define nationalism.
Steinhoff scandal knocks US$12 billion off value in blow to tycoon Wiese -World News
Steinhoff scandal knocks US$12 billion off value in blow to tycoon Wiese 4 days ago
JOHANNESBURG/BERLIN: Shocked Steinhoff shareholders have wiped more than US$12 billion off its value since it revealed "accounting irregularities" and parted ways with its chief executive, in a dramatic fall from grace for the South African retailer. Onc
Football: Fifth Ballon d'Or fitting record for great Ronaldo -World News
Football: Fifth Ballon d'Or fitting record for great Ronaldo 4 days ago
PARIS: For much of Cristiano Ronaldo's career he has been in direct competition with Barcelona talisman Lionel Messi, both for club and individual honours, so it's fitting that the Real Madrid superstar has the same number of Ballon d'Or awards. Ronaldo
US judge sets March trial for AT&T-Time Warner merger case -World News
US judge sets March trial for AT&T-Time Warner merger case 4 days ago
The judge who will oversee the U.S. Justice Department's bid to stop wireless and pay TV company AT&T Corp from buying media company Time Warner Inc , on Thursday set March 19 as the trial date.