Judge instructs jury in Babcock case about

Judge instructs jury in Babcock case about "complex" body of circumstantial evidence

Credit: ctvnews.ca

  • Dec 07 2017 19:35About: 4 days ago
  • 8 views

TORONTO -- The judge at the trial of two men accused of killing a young Toronto woman five years ago and then burning her body is instructing the jury on how to deal with circumstantial evidence.

Justice Michael Code began his 300-page charge to the jury this morning in the first-degree murder trial of Dellen Millard and Mark Smich in the presumed death of 23-year-old Laura Babcock, whose body has not been found.

The judge says the case hinges upon a "large and complex" body of circumstantial evidence about two main issues: whether Babcock is dead and whether Millard and Smich caused her death from an unlawful act.

The prosecution alleges Babcock was killed in the summer of 2012 after becoming the odd woman out in a love triangle with Millard and his girlfriend, Christina Noudga.

Millard, 32, of Toronto and Smich, 30, of Oakville, Ont., have pleaded not guilty and both have said the Crown has not proved that Babcock is dead.

The judge told the jury his instruction will last multiple days before they can begin deliberating.

"Facts may be proved by circumstantial evidence," Code said.

"It is all about inference drawing. You observe some fact and from that fact you draw an inference or conclusion."

The judge hammered home the point multiple times Thursday that circumstantial evidence must be looked in totality, not each piece of evidence in isolation.

He summarized seven key points of circumstantial evidence that came up throughout the seven-week trial: motive, opportunity, evidence of the incinerator and Millard's handgun purchase, Babcock's disappearance, her risky lifestyle, the use of the incinerator on July 23, 2012, and statements made by Millard and Smich after the Toronto woman disappeared.

In its closing address on Wednesday, the Crown said a "mountain" of circumstantial evidence points to Millard and Smich killing Babcock at Millard's home some time after 8 p.m. on July 3, 2012 and then disposing of her body at Millard's farm near Waterloo, Ont.

Smich's lawyer told the jury on Wednesday that his client had no motive to kill Babcock because he was never part of a love triangle and all the Crown has is a rap song in which Smich says he killed a girl and burned her body.

Millard, who is representing himself, told the jury in his closing address earlier this week that several witnesses testified to having seen or heard from Babcock after July 4, 2012.



Follow Us on Twitter

judge trial accused killing young Toronto woman five years then burning body begin legal instructions jury today.

Related stories with Judge instructs jury in Babcock case about "complex" body of circumstantial evidence

New Beyond Good And Evil 2 Video Shows Off The Game's Progress -World News
New Beyond Good And Evil 2 Video Shows Off The Game's Progress 4 days ago
Following its surprise reveal at E3, Ubisoft has now released a new video showcasing Beyond Good & Evil 2. Rather than a typical trailer, it features a mixture of gameplay footage and interviews with the developers, who continue to attempt a more open
Overwatch Winter Wonderland CONFIRMED: Blizzard’s Christmas event skins return in 2017 -World News
Overwatch Winter Wonderland CONFIRMED: Blizzard’s Christmas event skins return in 2017 4 days ago
THE OVERWATCH Winter Wonderland, Blizzard’s Christmas event, will be returning in 2017 and will include a new mode and festive skins.
Schmidt Peterson Motorsports cans Tristan Gommendy Indy 500 deal -World News
Schmidt Peterson Motorsports cans Tristan Gommendy Indy 500 deal 4 days ago
IndyCar's Schmidt Peterson Motorsports has cancelled its Indianapolis 500 partnership with former Formula 1 team co-owner Didier Calmels and former Champ Car driver Tristan Gommendy
Lindsay Lohan makes rare red carpet appearance, says 'We need the whole cast' for 'Mean Girls' sequel -World News
Lindsay Lohan makes rare red carpet appearance, says 'We need the whole cast' for 'Mean Girls' sequel 4 days ago
Lindsay Lohan made a rare red carpet appearance with her mother, Dina Lohan, on Wednesday night at the The Daily Mail’s holiday part in New York City.
Banking Apps Found Vulnerable to MITM Attacks -World News
Banking Apps Found Vulnerable to MITM Attacks 4 days ago
Using a free tool called Spinner, researchers identified certificate pinning vulnerabilities in mobile banking apps that left customers vulnerable to man-in-the-middle attacks.
Burnham Invited to Curtis Cup Practice Session -World News
Burnham Invited to Curtis Cup Practice Session 4 days ago
Dec. 7, 2017 Michigan State senior Sarah Burnham has been selected as one of 12 players to participate in a practice session in advance of the 2018 Curtis Cup Match. The session for prospective players will take place Dec. 17-18 at Shoal Creek in Alabama,
Emily Ratajkowski mocks Piers Morgan's criticism of her sexy video -World News
Emily Ratajkowski mocks Piers Morgan's criticism of her sexy video 4 days ago
Emily Ratajkowski fired back at Piers Morgan’s claim that she was not a feminist and his criticism of a sexy video she did for Love magazine.
Manhart MHX6 Dirt² is the off-road BMW X6 M you didn’t ask for but might want -World News
Manhart MHX6 Dirt² is the off-road BMW X6 M you didn’t ask for but might want 4 days ago
The BMW X6 M is already the answer to a problem no one had. Despite its complete superfluity, the X6 M is a charming car, … The article Manhart MHX6 Dirt² is the off-road BMW X6 M you didn’t ask for but might want appeared first on BMW BLOG
A look at BMW M Division’s future product offensive -World News
A look at BMW M Division’s future product offensive 4 days ago
BMW M CEO Frank van Meel is knows that the M Division is in need of a boost if it wants to catch up to … The article A look at BMW M Division’s future product offensive appeared first on BMW BLOG
Ford makes way for autonomous car facility by moving new EV plant to Mexico -World News
Ford makes way for autonomous car facility by moving new EV plant to Mexico 4 days ago
Filed under: Plants/Manufacturing,Ford,Autonomous,Electric,Hybrid The move means an additional $200 million and 150 more jobs for Flat Rock.Continue reading Ford makes way for autonomous car facility by moving new EV plant to Mex
Senator Al Franken announces resignation because of sexual harassment charges -World News
Senator Al Franken announces resignation because of sexual harassment charges 4 days ago
Democratic Senator Al Franken said on Thursday he plans to resign after more than a half-dozen women came forward over the past several weeks with allegations that he touched them improperly or made unwanted sexual advances. Franken also disputed some of
Re: Saudi offers Abu Dis as future capital of Palestine -World News
Re: Saudi offers Abu Dis as future capital of Palestine 4 days ago
A Saudi proposal for a peace initiative between Israelis and Palestinians offers the village of Abu Dis as the future capital of Palestine instead of East Jerusalem, stirring widespread anger. Acti...