Opinion: 'Singling out diesels is a facile solution to a complex problem' -

Opinion: 'Singling out diesels is a facile solution to a complex problem'

Credit: autocar.co.uk

  • Dec 08 2017 01:20About: 3 days ago
  • 6 views
Sometimes, what’s good for the environment is bad for people liking the government
This week, we discuss the Government's rather bonkers response to dieselgate and why motorists want better public transport

I suppose we should talk diesel, what with the budget and everything, which has cleared up, what, exactly? Not a lot, I think. If I understand correctly, there’ll be a tax hike on diesel cars that don’t meet an emissions standard that doesn’t exist yet. Clear? Right.

It’s because, I think, we must be seen to do something, even though the truth of it is that government can’t do too much because, sometimes, what’s good for the environment is bad for people liking them.

They incentivised us to buy diesels to lower carbon dioxide emissions – that one probably hasn’t gone away, either, by the way – so they can’t just charge us a fortune now for doing what we were told then. I mean, it might be better for the planet and all, but it’s also a sure-fire way to rubbish the economy and find you’re an ex-politician in need of a job. And there are only so many available spaces on Strictly Come Dancing.

So the idea is to gently ease those who thought they were doing the right thing in the first place into doing something else. Except that it won’t work because it’s discouraging people from buying new, fairly clean diesels instead and reducing the values of, and demand for, older diesels, making getting out of one financially unviable.

And all without, probably, making much actual difference to the air we breathe – except that we’re now breathing it with even unhealthier levels of exasperation.

I suppose we’ll see, but poor urban air quality consists of such a hotchpotch of emissions – from private cars, public transport, light and heavy goods vehicles, brake discs, ports, wood burners and more – that it’ll take years to see how much removing one source matters. And because we keep buying stuff and diesel is currently the only way to transport it, and because the amount of stuff we buy seems to be some kind of measure of national success and happiness, and because it keeps people in work and tax money rolling in, nobody wants to stop that, either. It’s all bonkers, this, isn’t it?

The fundamental issues, though, go deeper again. We force people to live in urban areas because we don’t build enough houses anywhere else, then find it surprising that the traffic is bad. There are about eight million more of us living in the UK than there were 20 years ago – about half because we’re living longer and the other half because it’s quite a nice place – but housing and infrastructure hasn’t kept pace with the increase. There are loads of places with great air quality. If we all spread out a bit, surely that would help more than a few quid extra tax?

Some say that we should improve public transport and use that instead. It’s a noble idea, but why do most of us really want better public transport? Quite. So the roads are freer to make life easier for us when to drive places, because we’ll have things to carry – child seats, sporting equipment, shopping, a heavy cold, Test Match Special or a bad mood – that we can’t bear to share with other people.

So here we are. Different day, same problems. It’s no good the car industry complaining, of course. You had your chance on that score, but fiddling the numbers ruined it for everyone. Well done. And thanks.



Follow Us on Twitter

Sometimes what’s good environment people liking government This week...

Related stories with Opinion: 'Singling out diesels is a facile solution to a complex problem'

After-School Worker Accused of Raping 13-Year-Old Student -World News
After-School Worker Accused of Raping 13-Year-Old Student 3 days ago
NEW YORK — A New York City after-school counselor was arrested Wednesday night on suspicion of raping a 13-year-old girl, police said. Michael Jenkins, 24, supervises students at Angelo Patri Middle School on Webster Avenue at Folin Street in Fordham H
‘Neighbor Helping Neighbor’: Firefighters from Several States Arrive to help California Crews -World News
‘Neighbor Helping Neighbor’: Firefighters from Several States Arrive to help California Crews 3 days ago
LOS ANGELES – With Santa Ana winds predicted to continuing gusting through the weekend, firefighters are arriving from across much of the western U.S. to provided much-needed relief to Southern California agencies. Strike teams have arrived from Nevada,
NJPW World Tag League Ends This Week; Final Match Cards, Viewing Info & Teams Still in Contention -World News
NJPW World Tag League Ends This Week; Final Match Cards, Viewing Info & Teams Still in Contention 3 days ago
We are down to the last three days of the NJPW World Tag League, where the winner will go on to face Suzuki Gun’s Killer Elite Squad for the IWGP Heavyweight Tag Team Championship at Wrestle Kingdom 12. There are still at least eight different teams in
Former WWE Star Gives Sasha Banks Props, Triple H And Jinder Mahal Hype Upcoming Match, WWE Shop -World News
Former WWE Star Gives Sasha Banks Props, Triple H And Jinder Mahal Hype Upcoming Match, WWE Shop 3 days ago
Former WWE Star Gives Sasha Banks Props, Triple H And Jinder Mahal Hype Upcoming Match, WWE Shop
‘Khaki Bandit’ believed to be responsible for Groveland bank robbery -World News
‘Khaki Bandit’ believed to be responsible for Groveland bank robbery 3 days ago
Tuolumne County sheriff's officials and the FBI believe a man who robbed a Groveland bank is the “Khaki Bandit” involved in 13 heists throughout California.
The Grand Tour season 2: Richard Hammond's car crash is SO much worse than you thought -World News
The Grand Tour season 2: Richard Hammond's car crash is SO much worse than you thought 3 days ago
THE GRAND TOUR star Richard Hammond suffered an horrific car crash while filming the second season of the Amazon series - but it could have been so much worse.
Trump's Jerusalem move: US warns against scrapping Abbas talks -World News
Trump's Jerusalem move: US warns against scrapping Abbas talks 3 days ago
Talks between US Vice-President Pence and Palestinian leader Abbas are planned for later this month.
Accidental mission -World News
Accidental mission 3 days ago
How an American Mormon grandmother ended up running a Greek refugee camp.
Is the doner skewered?  -World News
Is the doner skewered? 3 days ago
Does a vote in the European Parliament mean the doner kebab could be skewered? The BBC's Laurence Peter investigates.
Irish border: New draft Brexit plan could break deadlock -World News
Irish border: New draft Brexit plan could break deadlock 3 days ago
There are "serious ideas" on the table, a source says, as talks over the Irish border go into the night.
Ford Will Build Electric Cars in Mexico, Shifting Its Plan -World News
Ford Will Build Electric Cars in Mexico, Shifting Its Plan 3 days ago
The automaker said it would devote a Michigan plant to driverless vehicles instead, with a bigger investment and more jobs.
Possible Mazda RX-9 Mule Caught Testing -World News
Possible Mazda RX-9 Mule Caught Testing 3 days ago
Ever since the Mazda RX-8 went out of production, and even before then, rumors of a rotary-powered successor have refused to die. That’s, of course, partly because Mazda keeps reminding us that it has a dedicated team of engineers working on a way