Review: ‘A Room in India’ Overflows With Astonishing Visions -

Review: ‘A Room in India’ Overflows With Astonishing Visions

Credit: nytimes.com

  • Dec 07 2017 22:25About: 4 days ago
  • 6 views


Funny how four hours doesn’t feel so long when you are given the whole world in exchange.

And that’s what’s on offer in the Théâtre du Soleil’s boundary-busting production of “A Room in India,” which opened Tuesday night at the Park Avenue Armory: The whole awful, silly, disturbing, mystifying, contradictory world in one sitting.

Perhaps that bounty is to be expected from a theater collective whose 100 members, representing 26 nationalities, each get a say in the proceedings (and identical portions of meals at their Paris base). And yet even in comparison with other Soleil productions — including “Les Éphémères,” which appeared at the Amory in 2009 — there is something especially anarchic and encompassing about “A Room in India.” It sometimes feels like watching a chicken dance with its head cut off.

Which is hardly to call Ariane Mnouchkine — who helped found the company in 1964 and is the director of “A Room in India” — a chicken. But in response to the November 2015 terrorist attack on Paris that killed 130 people, she did offer the members of her troupe a rather zany prompt: What if a theater company much like their own, in residence in a former French colonial town in India, discovered that its director had gone mad and left the group to fulfill an important commission on the fly?




“A Room in India” is, and is not, the result. It does take place in Pondicherry, India, and the director — a male character pointedly named Lear — has indeed gone off the deep end, cavorting about town naked and desecrating the local statue of Gandhi. The job of creating the commission somehow falls to an unimaginative assistant, Cornélia, even though she has never in her life “managed to produce a single artistic gesture.”


But instead of showing us what the dizzy Cornélia (Hélène Cinque) comes up with, “A Room in India” gives us an encyclopedia of the anxious visions she dreams one night while seeking a suitable subject. These visions, which come to life in the vast room of the title, range both in style and in content through many of the world’s theatrical traditions and a heaping helping of its oddities and ills.













Among the genres traversed are farce, adventure, social realism, puppetry, Japanese drama and YouTube documentary. (Shakespeare, Chekhov, a cow and two macaques all make appearances, because why not.) Among the terrible topics covered are ecological disaster, the Syrian civil war, Hindu-Muslim enmity, the death of culture and, naturally, terrorism. In one horrific scene, the company’s artists, instead of sewing costumes, produce a tiny explosive vest for a little boy to wear on a suicide mission.




And yet this image is quickly wiped away, as all the visions are, by the ringing of a loud phone that wakes Cornélia from her feverish sleep. “A Room in India” is more interested in the process of creation than in the product, perhaps because, as Cornélia fears, a product may never be precise enough to be, or do, good.

Though the work’s structure is comically recursive, eventually the visions point more insistently toward one subject and one style. The subject is the disempowerment of women, especially in Indian and Arab cultures. In an affecting flashback that somehow winds up in Cornélia’s dream, her landlady in Pondicherry, a Hindu schoolteacher called Madam Murti (Nirupama Nityanandan), is forcibly separated from the man she loves by her bullying brother, bent on honor.

At another point, a group of Saudi Arabian bureaucrats seeking advice about improving their country’s record on women’s rights is shown videoconferencing with Icelandic officials. The hysterical response of the Saudis to the cheerful Icelanders — a lesbian, a gay man and a woman whose husband stays home to care for the children — is presented as a smutty sex comedy.




This is striking. Though Ms. Mnouchkine is more of a blithe cultural appropriator than a purveyor of stereotypes, the sex-crazed sheikhs seem to go too far. “A Room in India” also tries, with mixed success, to see if terrorists can be made funny, in the manner of the Keystone Kops. And yet, for all of the company’s catholic tastes, there are lines of relativism it will not cross. Thus, as Cornélia narrows in on the Mahabharata as her source, she chooses (or is chosen by) two stories — “The Rape of Draupadi” and the “Death of Karna”— that highlight women’s agency and ingenuity.

The stories are staged in the Terukkuttu theatrical style of South India, a tradition rich with ornate singing and dancing but also with gorgeous costumes and clever stage tricks. As part of an attempt by her husband to humiliate her, Draupadi (Judit Janscó) is to be stripped of her sari but foils the plan by wearing what seem to be hundreds. Spinning like a bobbin, she wraps fabric around her body as fast as others can pull it off.

And even though the other story, about a warrior and his wife (Shaghayegh Beheshti), is more tragic, she is allowed the great dignity of marital love and grief. You need not understand the Tamil words (or read the supertitles) to be knocked over by the sung power of her feelings.


Still, I can’t say I fully understood why the two Mahabharata stories were featured as the culmination of all the others. Surely, Cornélia’s earlier visions were just as compelling, filled with pressing dangers to both the world and the theater. (One subplot involves an absurd ministerial inquiry into the purpose and efficacy of art.) And the attempted denouement, in which a Chaplinesque ayatollah delivers a peroration, untied nothing for me.


But upon reflection — and, to be honest, amid all the hoopla, you have ample time for reflection — I came to feel a new and helpful idea arising from the crazy stew of delicious visions. Which is that the story of women, the story Cornélia finally settles upon, is not an outlier to the other concerns raised by “A Room in India.” Rather, it is the central story. In Ms. Mnouchkine’s imagination, and maybe finally ours, the theater is a woman, and so is the world.











Follow Us on Twitter

Théâtre Soleil brings huge dizzy epic world’s ills (and theatrical styles) Park Avenue Armory.

Related stories with Review: ‘A Room in India’ Overflows With Astonishing Visions

Arlington Police's 10 Most Wanted Criminals, December 6 -World News
Arlington Police's 10 Most Wanted Criminals, December 6 4 days ago
Arlington Police are looking for these 10 fugitives. Crime Stoppers will pay up to $1,000 for information leading to an arrest. Call 817-469-8477.
Folsom Ice Rink Now Open -World News
Folsom Ice Rink Now Open 4 days ago
The Folsom Ice Rink is now open, and Gary is out on the ice checking it out. Skate session: $12 plus $3 skate rental for general admission. $10 kids (8 years old & under), and $10.00 for age 62 and over and $3 skate rental. Each session is 90 minutes
Tarrant County's 10 Most Wanted Criminals, December 6 -World News
Tarrant County's 10 Most Wanted Criminals, December 6 4 days ago
Fort Worth Police and the Tarrant County Sheriff's Office are looking for these 10 fugitives. Crime Stoppers will pay up to $1,000 for information leading to an arrest. Call 817-469-8477.
Holidays at The Ritz Carlton in Lake Tahoe -World News
Holidays at The Ritz Carlton in Lake Tahoe 4 days ago
Martina is in the kitchen with Executive Chef Mark Jeffers trying her best to recreate his whole roasted chicken with root vegetables.
I'm A Celebrity 2017: Amir Khan launches worst attack yet on Iain Lee 'You f***ed it' -World News
I'm A Celebrity 2017: Amir Khan launches worst attack yet on Iain Lee 'You f***ed it' 4 days ago
I’M A CELEBRITY… GET ME OUT OF HERE! star Amir Khan shocked fans by launching yet another vicious attack on Iain Lee during tonight’s instalment.
Ric Flair On His Recent Hospitalization, Learning to Walk Again, Matt Lauer “Blowing” His NBC Deal, Life Advice -World News
Ric Flair On His Recent Hospitalization, Learning to Walk Again, Matt Lauer “Blowing” His NBC Deal, Life Advice 4 days ago
Ric Flair Discusses His Recent Hospitalization, Matt Lauer "Blowing" His NBC Deal, Life Advice, Falling Off a Boat and Ricky Morton Saving Him, More!
John Cena Speaks Mandarin On Fallon (Video), Watch Second Season Of
John Cena Speaks Mandarin On Fallon (Video), Watch Second Season Of "But I'm Chris Jericho!", Stock 4 days ago
John Cena Speaks Mandarin On Fallon (Video), Watch Second Season Of "But I'm Chris Jericho!", Stock
Angelina Love Talks WWE Debut Getting Nixed In 2006 While She Was In The Crowd -World News
Angelina Love Talks WWE Debut Getting Nixed In 2006 While She Was In The Crowd 4 days ago
Angelina Love Talks WWE Debut Getting Nixed In 2006 While She Was In The Crowd
Last Minute Christmas & New Year Charter Yachts and Specials -World News
Last Minute Christmas & New Year Charter Yachts and Specials 4 days ago
There’s still time to leave the winter blues behind and begin 2018 aboard an astounding superyacht: Host a lavish dock-side party, spend time together with family and friends in tranquil surroundings or learn new skills to make your holiday a truly uniq
Jimmy Jacobs On If Vince McMahon Liked His Writing, Drug Addiction While With WWE, WWE Departure -World News
Jimmy Jacobs On If Vince McMahon Liked His Writing, Drug Addiction While With WWE, WWE Departure 4 days ago
Jimmy Jacobs On If Vince McMahon Liked His Writing, Drug Addiction While With WWE, WWE Departure
Rumor Killer On Wrestler Expected To Sign With WWE, Post-WrestleMania RAW & SD Presale, Byron Saxton -World News
Rumor Killer On Wrestler Expected To Sign With WWE, Post-WrestleMania RAW & SD Presale, Byron Saxton 4 days ago
Rumor Killer On Wrestler Expected To Sign With WWE, Post-WrestleMania RAW & SD Presale, Byron Saxton
I'm A Celebrity 2017: Toff swoops in to defend Iain Lee against Amir Khan in 'bullying' ro -World News
I'm A Celebrity 2017: Toff swoops in to defend Iain Lee against Amir Khan in 'bullying' ro 4 days ago
GEORGIA TOFFOLO lept to the defence of fellow I'm A Celebrity…Get Me Out Of Here! campmate Iain Lee when she heard Amir Khan and Jamie Lomas badmouthing him.