Why capital gains tax changes would be bad, but dividend tax changes would be worse

Credit: financialpost.com

The federal government’s budget will be released in a short few days (March 22) and there is no shortage of speculation on what it will contain. One of the most talked-about potential changes is to the inclusion rate on capital gains — or the portion an investor includes as taxable income on his/her tax annual tax filing.


The inclusion rate in Canada is currently 50 per cent but there are many worried that Ottawa will hike it to as high as 75 per cent. If true, this would not be without serious consequences as suddenly investors will lose an incentive for taking risk and as a result some of this money may be reallocated elsewhere.


Although there has not been any speculation about altering the tax treatment of dividends, any changes there would be equally concerning, especially in this low interest rate environment.


For example, imagine a retiree in Alberta living off the income generated from a $2 million portfolio invested 60 per cent in dividend stocks yielding of 3.5 per cent and 40 per cent in bonds yielding 2.0 per cent.


Currently, there is a tax credit on eligible dividends to account for the fact that they come out of after-tax corporate earnings. As a result, investors pay a lower rate on dividends than on regular income.



Under the current tax regime for 2017, we estimate that our retiree would pay approximately 4 per cent in tax leaving them with an annual after-tax income of approximately $55,800. If the dividends were taxed entirely as income along with the bond income, the tax-rate would rise to approximately 20 per cent, leaving the retiree with approximately $46,450 of after-tax income.


That said, for those still working and earning a large T4 income, capital gains currently appear to be more attractive with a slightly lower tax rate than dividend income under the current 50 per cent inclusion rate but would be slightly higher if changed to the 75 per cent inclusion rate.


These are all important considerations as changing tax rates will influence capital allocation decisions — something we hope our Federal government realizes. Suddenly lower-growth and less-risky dividend companies could have a lower tax rate to the investor than riskier and higher-growth companies such those in the small and mid-capitalization range.


While there is plenty of talk about equity markets setting new highs, in reality many investors who chased this growth generated only modest returns and would have done much worse if not for being bailed out by the dividends they received.


This is because many give into emotion and end up buying at market highs and selling at the market lows. Take those who return chased the equity market and bought at its March 2008 highs. Interestingly, the S&P TSX itself only gained an annualized 1.6 per cent over these nine years, but thankfully dividends came to the rescue boosting this return to an annualized 4.6 per cent.


Things get a lot worse for investors who bought developed equity markets outside of North America. Over the same period, we calculate that in USD terms, the MSCI EAFE index itself lost 1.8 per cent per year but with a positive 1.2 per cent annualized return after dividends.


The clear winner was the S&P 500, which returned an annualized 6.7 per cent over these nine years and a healthy 9.1 per cent when including dividends.


Finally, given that bonds posted a 4.2 per cent per year total return over this period, we calculate that the average Canadian-focused balanced portfolio with a 60/40 split generated a modest 4.4 per cent annualized return. This would have been only 3.0 per cent per year if not for the dividends received.


Besides bailing out those investors who buy and sell at the wrong time, dividends are also quite beneficial to those retirees who depend on tax-efficient income in this low interest rate and low return environment.


So let’s all hope there are minimal changes to the upcoming budget.


Martin Pelletier, CFA is a Portfolio Manager and OCIO at TriVest Wealth Counsel Ltd, a Calgary-based private client and institutional investment firm specializing in discretionary risk-managed portfolios as well as investment audit and oversight services.


Top Stories

Credit Suisse to Make Capital Hike Decision After AGM

The Swiss bank is considering a quick-fire share sale and other options.
  • 16 hours ago
  • 6

Germany Welcomes Macron Success in French Election First Round

Macron and far-right leader Marine Le Pen are leading in the official vote count.
  • 10 hours ago
  • 4

France’s Presidential Runoff Is A Victory For Global Business

Marine Le Pen and Emmanuel Macron will face off May 7.
  • 5 hours ago
  • 4

Is the end of FX sales teams nigh, as traditional calls make way for new fintech solutions?

FinanceFeeds - No pressure on Forex brokers' clients and lower costs for companies are amid the targets of OSYSTEMS' latest solution, Jonathan Frankenstein and Martins Skromans say. The post Is the end of FX sales teams nigh, as traditional calls make way for new fintech solutions? appeared first on FinanceFeeds.
  • 1 hour ago
  • 4

Public Window on Financial Complaints Could be Closing Soon

You might have to say goodbye to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's public database.
  • 17 hours ago
  • 4
farawayyachtingcharters - Easy Branches
botoxfillerveintheraphyinphuket - Easy Branches

Latest in Financial

Tesla’s Big Model 3 Bet Is Riding on This Risky Strategy

The decision by CEO Elon Musk is said to underscore his tolerance for high risk.
  • 7 minutes ago

The World’s Most Powerful Women: April 24

A must-read for every global businesswoman.
  • 7 minutes ago

North Korea Threatens to Sink U.S. Aircraft Carrier in a ‘Single Strike’

The USS Carl Vinson carrier strike group is headed toward the Korean Peninsula.
  • 7 minutes ago

Trump to Sign New Executive Orders That Enable Drilling and Mining in Previously Off Limit Areas

Trump is seeking to gut most of the climate change regulations put in place by Barack Obama.
  • 7 minutes ago

FX liquidity will always be solely centered in regions of political stability – Op Ed

FinanceFeeds - .....and that means just five places: Britain, North America, Singapore, Australia and remarkably, China The post FX liquidity will always be solely centered in regions of political stability – Op Ed appeared first on FinanceFeeds.
  • 26 minutes ago

Now Another Country Is Considering a Laptop Ban for Travelers

It would follow similar measures introduced last month by the U.S., Britain, and Australia.
  • 1 hour ago

Enforcer Gold Corp: Nose to the Ground

“I walked up the Galena Vein, about twenty meters north of a nice rock sample which turned out to assay over 510 grams per tonne gold. Nose to the ground. I took my hammer out and tried to break off a piece of rock where I could see some visible gold. The specimen was the size of the palm of my hand, it was loose, but it was stuck on something, I couldn’t believe my eyes when I realized it was stuck by a 1 inch piece of gold. I tried to keep a straight face, but honestly, I had never seen anything like that before, it is simply spectacular. That sample was never assayed, it’s just too pretty to waste on getting an assay number, I know the number would be extremely high, it’s museum quality” said Roebuck.
  • 1 hour ago

Is the end of FX sales teams nigh, as traditional calls make way for new fintech solutions?

FinanceFeeds - No pressure on Forex brokers' clients and lower costs for companies are amid the targets of OSYSTEMS' latest solution, Jonathan Frankenstein and Martins Skromans say. The post Is the end of FX sales teams nigh, as traditional calls make way for new fintech solutions? appeared first on FinanceFeeds.
  • 1 hour ago

World Leaders Should Ignore Trump on Climate, Says Michael Bloomberg

Bloomberg said the U.S. is already on track to meet its carbon emissions pledge.
  • 3 hours ago

France’s Presidential Runoff Is A Victory For Global Business

Marine Le Pen and Emmanuel Macron will face off May 7.
  • 5 hours ago

This Silicon Valley CEO Got Just Two Weeks In Jail for Domestic Violence

The DA was worried a felony conviction would cause the defendant to be deported.
  • 6 hours ago

3 Reasons You Should Consider Starting Your Own Business

One entrepreneur gives his take.
  • 6 hours ago