Trump’s threat of steel tariffs heralds big changes in trade policy


Trump’s threat of steel tariffs heralds big changes in trade policy

President Trump, accompanied by Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross and others, talks about an executive memorandum on investigating steel imports (Photo by Jabin Botsford/The Washington Post)

President Trump announced Thursday that he was directing the commerce secretary to investigate whether imports of steel were a threat to U.S. national security. This follows earlier administration plans to “self-initiate” – or start on its own – trade enforcement cases involving countries such as China, Mexico, Germany, Japan or South Korea.

Unlike many of Trump’s formal trade policy announcements, these moves could have an almost immediate impact. They will probably lead to more trade barriers and barriers that are poorly vetted. U.S. consumers will suffer, as well as manufacturers that rely on imported inputs to remain competitive, as will those companies’ employees.

While a political victory for anti-globalists, there will be unintended costs and redistribution. Self-initiated cases are also likely to raise barriers that don’t meet the international legal standards of the World Trade Organization, leading to disputes at the WTO and retaliation from trading partners.

Here’s how U.S. trade law works

To understand how self-initiation works, it’s first necessary to know what U.S. trade law is and who enforces it. Under U.S. trade law, trade cases fall into four baskets. The first is anti-dumping: Did unfairly low priced goods cause injury to U.S. firms? The second is countervailing duty: Did competitors to U.S. firms receive illegal government subsidies? Third is the safeguard: Has an unexpected surge in steel imports hurt the U.S. industry? Finally, comes the exception under which the administration can take action against imports that threaten national security.

These rules are implemented by two agencies. First is the Commerce Department, headed by Secretary Wilbur Ross. Under three of the four major U.S. trade laws, Commerce has a role as both an investigator and judge. The second is the International Trade Commission (ITC), which investigates whether there is “injury” under three of the laws. It has six members – three Democrats and three Republicans – and acts like a judge, determining whether the U.S. industry has suffered lost sales or lost jobs thanks to problematic imports.

Anti-dumping is the most frequently used of these policies in most major economies. In the United States, the ITC investigates whether the industry has been injured, and Commerce investigates the pricing – or “dumping” – question. If there is evidence of both, the U.S. government imposes new trade barriers. The two agencies investigate similar questions under the countervailing duty law. With the safeguard, only the ITC has a role, ensuring that the harm from an unexpected surge wasn’t mostly caused by alternative explanations like automation, a natural disaster, a U.S. labor strike, or bad managerial decisions. Finally, under Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962, Commerce investigates whether imports “threaten to impair” U.S. national security.

These laws offer different scope for presidential and administration authority

All this is important, because different laws offer different opportunities for the president. Decisions to impose anti-dumping or countervailing duties are handled by bureaucrats and are never supposed to reach the president’s desk. They also involve relatively well-defined international law, making it harder to take politicized decisions. Safeguards provide the most leeway for the White House to make political decisions – at the end of every investigation, the president makes the call on new trade barriers.

Finally, the national security exception allows the commerce secretary, or a number of other government officials and elected representatives, to trigger an investigation. However, WTO rules that might guide the process are much more poorly defined than is the case for anti-dumping, countervailing duties or safeguards.

Because there are no clearly accepted guidelines, the justification for use of the national security exception is also difficult to refute. It can, therefore, be easily abused. New import restrictions arising under that area of U.S. law really are akin to the “nuclear option” – their use really puts the entire system of international trade law at risk.

The U.S. government has self-initiated cases in the past – but not often

Typically, trade cases are started by U.S. workers, their companies or an industry association. These have been responsible for 99 percent of more than 2,000 investigations taking place since 1980. Self-initiated cases, where the U.S. government itself starts the process, have been extremely rare. Since the modern system of trade law was established in 1980, I have found only 19 instances in the data where the U.S. government fronted a case.

The most recent self-initiation was in 2001 and also covered steel. The George W. Bush administration launched a hotly contested safeguard investigation over $17 billion of imports. Nevertheless, my research shows that case had the same basic trade impact as the 1990s-era industry-initiated cases, when U.S. steel companies also complained about low prices. The main difference today is that ire now focuses on China, where much of the production is state-owned and takes place outside of normal market conditions.

In 1991, the George H. W. Bush administration started a countervailing duty case against softwood lumber imports from Canada. Like steel, that industry hardly needed the effort. Bush intervened immediately after Canada terminated a “voluntary” commitment to restrain wood trade that had been in effect since 1986. This particular trade irritant is also back and may be part of NAFTA renegotiations.

The Reagan administration self-initiated the last anti-dumping case in 1986 over a semiconductors dispute with Japan. But again, this came right after two similar disputes started by major U.S. semiconductor companies. Douglas Irwin at Dartmouth College has described the novelty of the semiconductors case as it eventually was packaged into a deal whereby Japan voluntarily agreed not only to restrain its own exports but also to expand imports from the U.S. semiconductor industry.

The national security exception has been used extremely rarely. However, in 2001, two members of Congress initiated an investigation into whether imports of iron ore and semi-finished steel were threatening U.S. national security. The timing of that case meant it was ultimately considered simultaneously with the Bush steel safeguard investigation, and thus there was little need for redundant import restrictions.

In general, industry doesn’t really need the U.S. government to initiate cases for it; firms do most of the initiating themselves. Contrary to myth, self-initiated cases don’t much help small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) to afford legal action –  a Government Accountability Office study from 2013 estimates that most legal costs arise well after the case has started. Indeed, the 19 self-initiated cases since 1980 seem to represent the wants of big firms in politically connected industries that could easily have started the cases themselves.

So what will self-initiated cases do?

It’s plausible that Trump wants more self-initiated cases simply to take political credit for protecting U.S. firms and jobs. Yet this approach will likely have costs.

First, they may create more trade barriers, inflicting pain on the U.S. economy. Steel tariffs would increase costs for U.S. manufacturers and construction companies that rely on imported inputs, making matters worse for U.S. consumers and taxpayers. Even if some U.S. steel jobs end up being saved, it would come at the expense of U.S. jobs in other sectors. And any new import taxes on other consumer or retail goods would likely be regressive – in other words, they would increase prices disproportionately for poorer Americans.

Second, there will likely be less evidence to support these new trade barriers, making them vulnerable to successful WTO actions from other countries. This weakens a 70-year-old U.S. commitment to promote the international rule of law and encourages others to engage in tit-for-tat retaliation. China did this repeatedly between 2009 and 2011, harming U.S. exports and workers in sectors as diverse as poultry, autos and steel.

Finally, these actions may be politically costly. They could open the way to new and harmful allegations of cronyism in the Trump administration. New barriers inevitably create winners and losers. The losers will ask whether the U.S. policymakers behind the self-initiating – whether in the White House, Commerce or Congress – are tilting the playing field to benefit certain U.S. industries and their own investment portfolios, at the expense of other Americans.

Chad P. Bown is a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics in Washington. He tracked global use of anti-dumping, countervailing duty, and safeguard policies for over a decade as the architect of the World Bank’s Temporary Trade Barriers Database. Follow him on Twitter @ChadBown.

Top Stories

Google Celebrates South Africa’s Freedom Day with Doodle Honoring Composer Enoch Sontonga

is marking the anniversary of South Africa’s first post-apartheid election on Thursday with a Doodle honoring 19th century composer Enoch Sontonga, who wrote a song that is now part of the country’s current national anthem. Sontonga, who was also a choirmaster and poet, composed the song Nkosi Sikelel’ iAfrika (God Bless Africa) in 1897. It…
  • 9 hours ago
  • 21

Shatta Wale’s Son “Shatta Majesty” Is All Grown Up Now And Looks Adorable

One of the hottest celebrity couples in Ama Ghana is Dancehall King Shatta Wale and Shatta Michy.   In 2015, they were blessed with a lovely son.   They named him Majesty Nii Armah-Mensah aka. Shatta Majesty. A post shared by @michygh on Feb 1, 2017 at 8:28pm PST   Fast forward to 2017 and […] The post Shatta Wale’s Son “Shatta Majesty” Is All Grown Up Now And Looks Adorable appeared first on OMGVoice.Com.
  • 4 days ago
  • 17

Arkansas Executes Two Inmates on the Same Gurney, Just Hours Apart

Two inmates received lethal injections Monday about three hours apart as Arkansas completed the nation's first double execution since 2000.
  • 2 days ago
  • 16

Republican Oversight Leader: Michael Flynn Apparently Broke the Law

"As a former military officer, you simply cannot take money from Russia"
  • 2 days ago
  • 15

Capturing the Beauty of Springtime in Iraqi Kurdistan

In Iraqi Kurdistan, spring is the time for lavish picnics
  • 2 days ago
  • 11

Are You Looking for More?
Check this out ...


farawayyachtingcharters - Easy Branches
botoxfillerveintheraphyinphuket - Easy Branches

Latest in Regions

15 Computer Games We’re Pretty Sure You Played As A Child

If you were a 90s kid, you probably got to play a lot of fun games. Remember going to the game centre to play these games on SNES or PlayStation? Here are some games you must have loved as a child! 1. Snake Game   2. Bounce   3. Brick game   4. Minesweeper   […] The post 15 Computer Games We’re Pretty Sure You Played As A Child appeared first on OMGVoice.Com.
  • 7 minutes ago

Aww! This Man’s Note To His Wife Is The Most Adorable Stuff Ever

We love so much and sometimes, little acts just make us all sorts of emotional and stuff. We’re still hard guys though We came across this tweet that had us screaming goals all over the whole place because it’s so adorable. My father is the definition of Husband Goals
  • 7 minutes ago

Marco Rubio: President Trump Should Strengthen America’s Relationship With Argentina

'America must act quickly to formalize improved relations'
  • 54 minutes ago

Why won’t Congress really investigate the Trump campaign’s ties to Russia?

Politicians, pundits, and scholars alike routinely call Congress the “broken branch.” Most often, they note its abysmally low level of legislative productivity recently, a trend that even the return of unified Republican control of government has failed to reverse. But Congress’s feeble efforts to investigate Russian interference in the 2016 election may be an even […]
  • 55 minutes ago

IIM Ahmedabad director Ashish Nanda resigns a year before his tenure ends

Ashish Nanda, a 1983 batch alumnus of IIM-A, took charge of the top post in September 2013 and his tenure was slated to end next year.
  • 55 minutes ago

Former Ghana President John Agyekum Kufuor Just Got Honoured In Freemason

This is His Excellency, John Agyekum Kufuor.   He is the former president of the Republic of Ghana.   John Agyekum Kufuor is a member of the Freemason. VW Bro HE John Kofi Agyekum Kufuor, PGSwdB, former President of the Republic of Ghana, has been appointed Senior Grand Warden — UGLE – Grand Lodge […] The post Former Ghana President John Agyekum Kufuor Just Got Honoured In Freemason appeared first on OMGVoice.Com.
  • 1 hour ago

6 Ways To Relieve ‘Homa’ Without Taking Medicine

Most of us Kenyans refer to a cold as homa. Everyone gets a homa from time to time and it’s normal to rush to a clinic or chemist to get medicine.But did you know that there are plenty of home remedies that can alleviate your homa symptoms and get you back to normal. Here are […] The post 6 Ways To Relieve ‘Homa’ Without Taking Medicine appeared first on OMGVoice.Com.
  • 1 hour ago

Someone Made A Thread About Kings Greater Than The Oba Of Lagos And It’s Hilarious

Nigerian twitter is too lit! So we told you that the Oba of Lagos snubbed the Ooni of Ife when he tried to greet him. The funny thing is, the Ooni of Ife is higher in rank than the Oba of Lagos and was not even supposed to greet him in the first place. @_achmed […] The post Someone Made A Thread About Kings Greater Than The Oba Of Lagos And It’s Hilarious appeared first on OMGVoice.Com.
  • 1 hour ago

Did Trump just take an ax to the U.S. trade relationship with Canada?

On Monday, Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross announced the United States had found preliminary evidence that Canada was subsidizing exports of softwood lumber. As a result, the United States would begin imposing new 20 percent tariffs on wood imports. Monday’s announcement raised eyebrows, in part because of President Trump’s controversial decision that the U.S. government would […]
  • 2 hours ago

India successfully test fires nuclear capable Agni-III missile off Odisha coast

Agni-III, capable of carrying both conventional and nuclear warheads weighing up to 1.5 tonnes, is 17 m tall.
  • 2 hours ago

10 Of The Best Twitter Reactions To President Buhari Working From Home

On Wednesday, the 26th April 2017, the President of Nigeria, Muhammadu Buhari announced that he will be absent from work. The Minister of Information, Lai Mohammed notified the cabinet members that the president sent word that he wanted to rest and asked the vice-president to preside over the executive council meeting. He also asked that […] The post 10 Of The Best Twitter Reactions To President Buhari Working From Home appeared first on OMGVoice.Com.
  • 2 hours ago

This Corps Member Is Trekking From Umuahia To Port-Harcourt For The Love Of His State

Say hello to corps member, Dave. Before y'all Start Flooding my Timeline and inbox with congratulatory Messages Like Happy Passing out, Happy POP etc, Lehme jez clear the Air… Based on Logistics I ain't passing out yet until 3rd of May… Still on still Congratulations to my Colleagues In Stream1 a Successful Passing Out Parade […] The post This Corps Member Is Trekking From Umuahia To Port-Harcourt For The Love Of His State appeared first on OMGVoice.Com.
  • 2 hours ago