The Real History to Know Before You See The Promise

Credit: time.com


When The Promise arrives in theaters on Friday, the film — starring Oscar Isaac, Charlotte Le Bon and Christian Bale — will do so just in time: its dramatization of a story that takes place amid the slaughter of Armenian citizens by the Ottoman Empire coincides with the annual day of remembrance in Armenia on April 24.


On that day in 1915, hundreds of Armenian intellectuals were arrested in what is believed to be the start of what’s widely known as the Armenian genocide, though the use of that terminology remains controversial more than a century later. During World War I, the Ottoman government’s ruling party, led by a triumvirate often known as the “Three Pashas,” concocted a plan to eradicate their Armenian population, the largest Christian minority in Turkey at the time. The plan led to laws permitting the confiscation of Armenians’ property and the deportation of these citizens, by methods including by marches to concentration camps in the Syrian desert during which many died along the way.


There were about 2.1 million Armenians living in the Ottoman empire in 1914, and about 387,800 by 1922, according to The University of Minnesota’s Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies.


“Armenians had become forces for social and political change within the empire and were asking the state, Can a Christian be the equal of a Muslim in the Ottoman empire?” says Peter Balakian, who won the 2016 Pulitzer Prize in poetry for Ozone Journal, his book of poems recounting his experience excavating the bones of Armenian victims in the Syrian desert with TV journalists in 2009. “The new nationalism in Turkey, especially after Turkey’s enormous losses in the Balkan wars, [led to the feeling] that Turkey could only be revived and saved if it got rid of its Christian minority populations. There are similarities with Nazism, in terms of thinking that, in order to revitalize a state in crisis, you need to eradicate a certain ethnic group.” (In fact, evidence shows that Adolf Hitler spoke of how what happened in Turkey influenced his plans to wipe out the Jewish population.)


“It’s a watershed event in the history of modernity,” says Balakian, “because it’s the first time that the nation-state uses technology its advanced military communications, legislation and the nationalist ideology for the purpose of eradicating a targeted ethnic group in a certain period of time.”


Get your history fix in one place: sign up for the weekly TIME History newsletter


Since then, Armenians have been trying for decades to get Turkish authorities — and other authorities around the world — to recognize the treatment of Armenian citizens of the Ottoman Empire as a genocide. For their part, those on the other side contend that the deaths in question took place amid a larger World War I context, in which they would not qualify as a genocide.


In October of 2007, as the U.S. House of Representatives debated whether to pass a resolution specifically condemning the Armenian genocide of 1915, in those words, Samantha Power (then a foreign policy advisor on Barack Obama’s 2008 presidential campaign) argued in the Oct. 29, 2007, issue of TIME that the House should do so. Even though it may have seemed that there was too much at stake regarding U.S.-Turkish relations — Some 70% of U.S. air cargo en route to Iraq passes through Turkey, as does about one-third of the fuel used by the U.S. military there,” she explained — she argued that the consequences of Turkish anger over such an action would be minimal:


The U.S. brought Turkey into NATO, built up its military and backed its membership in the European Union. Washington granted most-favored-nation trading status to Turkey, resulting in some $7 billion in annual trade between the two countries and $2 billion in U.S. investments there. Only Israel and Egypt outrank Turkey as recipients of U.S. foreign assistance. And…for all the help Turkey has given the U.S. concerning Iraq, Ankara turned down Washington’s request to use Turkish bases to launch the Iraq invasion, and it ignored Washington’s protests by massing 60,000 troops at the Iraq border this month as a prelude to a widely expected attack in Iraqi Kurdistan. In other words, while Turkey may invoke the genocide resolution as grounds for ignoring U.S. wishes, it has a longer history of snubbing Washington when it wants to.


The U.S. House Committee on Foreign Affairs voted to pass the resolution 27-21, but it didn’t make it to the House floor for a full vote. The same thing happened in 2010.


Still, Barack Obama broke his campaign promise to call the killings “genocide,” referring to the incident in a speech for Armenian Genocide Remembrance Day as “the first mass atrocity of the 20th century.” At least 26 countries have recognized the “Armenian genocide” as such, according to the Armenian National Institute.


As the world still comes to grips with what happened in 1915, Balakian sums up one reason the effort to do so matters: “Unresolved history is too big a burden to carry.”

Top Stories

Google Doodle Honors American Indian Activist Richard Oakes

He led the occupation of Alcatraz Island in 1969
  • 2 days ago
  • 103

Family Looking for Man Who Saved Dog from American River

FAIR OAKS — Chuck the pit bull mix is actually well trained. Mom and daughter, Bing and Theresa Simard, have made sure of that. Which is why they didn’t see what happened Sunday coming. “It happened pretty quick. I didn’t realize he was going to go for it,” Theresa Simard said. Bing and Theresa were walking along the Sunrise boat launch, and everything was going fine, until all of a sudden Chuck spotted some ducks. “I could not hold it anymore, […]
  • 2 days ago
  • 43

Justice League Director Zack Snyder Steps Down From Film After Daughter’s Suicide

Joss Whedon will step in while Snyder focuses on his family
  • 1 day ago
  • 19

Caltrans: Tanker Truck Explosion near Highway 99 in Atwater, Roads Closed

ATWATER — Fire crews are on the scene of a possible Tanker explosion in Atwater near Highway 99. Southbound Highway 99 is closed at Westside Boulevard due to the tanker fire at Applegate Road. Caltrans says to expect delays in the area. There is no estimated time for the roads to reopen. Massive fire in Atwater CA pic.twitter.com/wfVvWBNCa6 — Greg Pina Colada (@pina250) May 23, 2017
  • 12 hours ago
  • 17

Amit Shah blames Congress for 'Kashmir problem'

Shah was received by Chandigarh BJP president Sanjay Tandon, the party's local MP Kirron Kher and others.
  • 2 days ago
  • 15

Are You Looking for More?
YOU CAN MAKE WEALTH REAL!!
Check this out ...

www.MakeWealthReal.Com

farawayyachtingcharters - Easy Branches
botoxfillerveintheraphyinphuket - Easy Branches

Latest in Regions

A Group of South Koreans Is Suing China For Polluting the Air Over Seoul

Many residents of the South Korean capital blame China for the city's poor air quality
  • 55 minutes ago

This Is The Place: Watch Poet Tony Walsh Read His Stirring Ode to Manchester

His evocation of the city's history and fighting spirit drew wild applause
  • 55 minutes ago

HBO Scraps Jon Stewart’s New Show

NEW YORK — Jon Stewart’s highly anticipated new HBO show has been scrapped. In a joint statement, Stewart and the network said they have decided not to proceed with a short-form digital animated project due to “technical issues.” “We all thought the project had great potential but there were technical issues in terms of production and distribution that proved too difficult given the quick turnaround and topical nature of the material,” they said. The network added that it has “some […]
  • 2 hours ago

11 Jurors Chosen for Cosby Trial

Eleven jurors have been picked thus far for the Bill Cosby trial after the second day of jury selection at the Allegheny County Courthouse in Pennsylvania. Cosby faces sexual offense charges that could land the former comedian in prison. Seven jurors are white men, three are white women and there is one black woman. The full jury will include 12 jurors and six alternates. They will be bused and sequestered in a hotel for the length of the trial, which […]
  • 2 hours ago

Tom Cruise Says Top Gun 2 Is ‘Definitely Happening’ And Filming Could Begin Next Year

Tom Cruise says the runway is clear for Top Gun 2
  • 2 hours ago

Meet Osito!

The Sacramento SPCA brought in a cute pup looking to be adopted into a new fur-ever home!  Meet Osito, a male 8-year-old Chihuahua mix.  Osito means “little bear” in Spanish and he just so happens to be bi-lingual!  The SSPCA is reducing adoption fees for all animals that are 5 years and older May 24th through the 28th.  Check out the SSPCA and give an animal a fur-ever home! More info: Sacramento SPCA 6201 Florin Perkins Road Sacramento, CA, 95828 […]
  • 3 hours ago

Track 7 Memorial Day Block Party!

Track 7 Brewing Co. is hosting their 2nd Annual Memorial Day Block Party this Saturday!  The free event will feature music from the New Orleans-style brass band, Element Brass Band, and also music all day by DJ’s James & Raina of Souls & Sounds Productions.  Slightly Skewed, Bella Familia Pizzeria, and Voyager World Cuisine food trucks will be there serving up some amazing food as well.  In addition, Track 7 will be releasing three new cans in limited quantities.  Celebrate Memorial Day […]
  • 3 hours ago

Find New Outfits for Your Next Getaway

Krazy Mary’s Boutique joined us to show off some of their incredible clothing options.  They offer some of the hottest fashions at great prices.  If you’re looking for outfits for your next weekend getaway, check out Krazy Mary’s Boutique! More info: Krazy Mary’s Boutique 3230 Folsom Blvd. (916) 442-6279 Facebook: KrazyMarysBoutique Twitter: @KrazyMarys Instagram: @KrazyMarys_SugarShack
  • 3 hours ago

Bank with Sierra Central Credit Union

John Cassidy of Sierra Central Credit Union talked to Gary and Lori about opening a checking account.  Sierra Central is a proud sponsor of Studio40 Live’s American Hero Wedding Giveaway and will be awarding one lucky couple with a checking account containing $500!  Banking is made easy with Sierra Central’s intuitive mobile application and a total of 18 branches to choose from.  Open your own checking account and bank the right way with Sierra Central Credit Union. More info: Sierra […]
  • 3 hours ago

Celebrate 63 Years of Jimboy’s Tacos!

Karen Knudson Freeman, president of Jimboy’s Tacos, joined Gary and Lori in the kitchen to talk about the 63rd anniversary of Jimboy’s.  To celebrate the occasion yesterday they rolled up a 63lb burrito, one pound per year!  They have stayed true to their roots by maintaining their same crowd favorite recipes since their inception.  Celebrate 63 years of Jimboy’s Tacos and get some tacos for this taco tuesday. More info: Jimboy’s Tacos 40 Restaurants -Northern CA -Southern CA -Nevada JimboysTacos.com […]
  • 3 hours ago

Toddler Dies After Mother’s Boyfriend Allegedly Performs ‘Wrestling Moves’

JEFFERSON COUNTY, Mo. – A couple face charges after a 2-year-old Missouri girl died days after authorities say her mother’s boyfriend performed “wrestling moves” on the toddler. Police accuse the girl’s mother, 19-year-old Cheyenne Cook, and 24-year-old Richard Gamache Jr., of torturing the child, identified only as “AC.” On May 16th, police and EMS responded to the 3800 block of Dorchester Court in House Springs, located about 30 miles southwest of St. Louis.  A child having seizures at the residence was taken […]
  • 3 hours ago

‘RIP My Darling’: Parents Confirm Daughter’s Death in Manchester Attack

The mother of 15-year-old Olivia Campbell — who attended the Ariana Grande concert in Manchester England, with a friend — confirmed her daughter’s death in a Facebook post. “RIP my darling precious gorgeous girl Olivia Campbell taken far far too soon go sing with the angels and keep smiling mummy loves you so much,” Charlotte Campbell said the post on her Facebook page early Wednesday local time. Olivia was registered as missing person No. 13 hours after the Manchester Arena […]
  • 3 hours ago