Philip Cross: How I learned to stop worrying and love the job-replacing robots


Dominic Barton, head of Finance Minister Bill Morneau’s economic advisers, recently repeated the doomsday scenario that automation will wipe out 40 per cent of the jobs that exist today, raising the spectre of mass unemployment. People are attracted to such gloomy forecasts because of our insecure relationship with machines, going back to the Luddites of the 19th century. Polls show a majority of Canadians feel automation will destroy jobs.

However, technology experts are evenly divided about whether automation will eliminate more jobs than it creates. Optimists argue that it’s the nature of work and the required skills that is changing, from the “technical, classroom-taught, left-brain skills” needed over the last two centuries to skills based on human social relationships, as Geoff Colvin writes in his book Humans Are Underrated. The economic historian Deirdre McCloskey estimates that one-quarter of GDP already is earned from “sweet talk in markets and management.”

This shift actually favours what humans are good at. The neuroscientist Michael Gazzaniga concluded that “Our big brains are there primarily to deal with social matters, not to … cogitate about the second law of thermodynamics.” Instead of the emphasis on logical or repetitive processes demanded by the industrial revolution, we will use our brains for what they are made for — creativity, empathy, reciprocity, art, storytelling, all skills involving social interaction and not logic.

There will always be a market for the type of intelligence that machines can’t replace

Machines can only replace the logic/math aspect of human intelligence. But there are many other types of intelligence that machines cannot replace, including spatial, interpersonal, naturalistic, linguistic, musical and kinesthetic. Machines lack creativity, empathy, humour, taste, courage or integrity. There will always be a market for these skills and values.

A change already is underway in the occupational mix of skills used in the workplace. Employment is falling in transactional occupations (bank tellers, checkout clerks) and in production jobs, but is growing in areas based on human interaction such as health and elderly care, teaching, daycare, counselling, and recreation services. This shift requires less formal education of people, as reflected in the recent decline in the skill premium for university graduates, after steadily rising for decades. The threat to university educators might be why they generate so many pessimistic portrayals of the future economy.

Some jobs won’t be missed; the French composer Claude Debussy’s brother was a “cesspool scavenger.” Boring, repetitive jobs are best left to robots; as Henry Ford complained, “Why is it every time I ask for a pair of hands, they come with a brain attached?” Some jobs don’t require brains, which instead are best applied in the workplace to interpersonal skills, not imitating a machine. The history of automation is that the jobs it eliminates are the ones humans do not do well — heavy grunt work in the 19th century, dull, repetitive work in the 20th century, making consistently good decisions in the 21st century (such as driving).

Nor will automation displace all routine jobs. Overdependence on automated production processes without human input makes them brittle and inflexible; ask anyone after they talk to an automated answering service. Over-reliance on robotic methods of decision-making led to the epic failure of judgment that caused a near meltdown of the global financial system in 2008. Ben Bernanke was refused a mortgage by a bank’s computer algorithm after leaving his job as head of the Federal Reserve Board. Machines work better when augmented by humans, not when left on their own. Computers can play chess, but they play better with guidance from an expert human player.

Forecasters also exaggerate the rate at which technological change impacts the workplace. Nine out of 10 workers today are in occupations that already existed a century ago. Some changes may seem inevitable, but still take time to arrive. The history of machine automation is that it does replace jobs, but slowly, allowing time for people to find new ways to employ their innate skills. The pace of technological change is especially glacial in government, where a bureaucratic environment of form-filling and routine regulation without creativity or empathy make it readily amenable to replacement by machine.

Economists have been forecasting technological unemployment so long it’s a wonder anyone listens to such predictions anymore. David Ricardo in the 19th century worried that machines would be “injurious to the labouring class.” Keynes misdiagnosed the source of rising unemployment in 1930, claiming “We are afflicted with a new disease of which some readers may not have heard the name, but which they will hear a great deal in the years to come — namely, technological unemployment.” President Kennedy’s advisers told him that the major domestic challenge was “to maintain full employment at a time when automation … is replacing men.” Walter Leontief in 1983 speculated workers would be permanently sidelined by technology, like horses were by vehicles. There is a deep irony that at the very moment economists worry about the secular stagnation of economic growth, we worry about jobs being threatened by secular innovation in technology. Profound innovation will create the income growth needed to boost the demand for labour.

Philip Cross is a Munk Senior Fellow at the Macdonald-Laurier Institute.

Popular Science

Top Stories

Intel and Big Banks Put $100 Million in Finance Tech Firm R3

Investors include HSBC, Bank of America, Wells Fargo, and more.
  • 2 days ago
  • 31

Different Ways Customer Information Can Benefit Your Business

Different Ways Customer Information Can Benefit Your Business It is not a secret that today’s customers are pickier – for the lack of a better word –
  • 3 days ago
  • 15

Saxo Bank’s bespoke focus continues as Open Banking initiatives strengthened via developer portal

FinanceFeeds - Saxo Bank has long committed itself to the development of ‘open’ systems for its commercial clients, FinanceFeeds’ Andrew Saks-McLeod having... The post Saxo Bank’s bespoke focus continues as Open Banking initiatives strengthened via developer portal appeared first on FinanceFeeds.
  • 3 days ago
  • 13

Plan to sell oil reserves evidence of growing swagger of U.S. energy industry ahead of OPEC meeting

The idea is being floated just as members of the OPEC members meet in Vienna on Thursday to discuss whether they will extend a six-month contract to reduce oil supplies
  • 2 days ago
  • 13

Morneau’s growth council to focus on unlocking business spending, broadening job skills help

The council's chair said the group's next report, due this fall, will outline ways to encourage more business investment with the aim of reversing several years of decline
  • 2 days ago
  • 13

Latest in Financial

You Won’t Believe What This CEO Does Every Morning

It might seem a bit crazy, but it works.
  • 20 minutes ago

History Says this Bull Market Can Add Another $2.4 Trillion in 2017

It's ended up 100% of the time in scenarios like this year.
  • 20 minutes ago

Farewell to the man who literally wrote the book on Canadian business

Joe Martin: Thirty years after its publication, Michael Bliss's classic is well worth reading
  • 30 minutes ago

Videotron appeals CRTC ruling to stop offering unlimited music service

Videotron says it wants more time to get rid of the plans to avoid 'significant and long-term reputational damage on its brand'
  • 1 hour ago

Quebec resort in town of Charlevoix to host next year’s G7 meetings, sources say

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is expected to make the announcement at some point during this year’s G7 meetings, which get underway Friday in Sicily
  • 1 hour ago

Chairman of besieged Liquor Stores says company’s plan is working

Barry Critchley: In an interview Jim Dinning, chair at Liquor Stores, was asked to explain why shareholders should support management — without mentioning the dissidents
  • 1 hour ago

Hollister Saves the Day as Abercrombie’s Sales Continue to Plunge

The CEO wants to tap the brand's 125 year history to fix it.
  • 2 hours ago

Google and Mark Zuckerberg Are Backing a New Way to Measure Criminal Justice

The group aims to collect data on 20 states by 2020
  • 2 hours ago

U.S. stocks freshen the record books as S&P 500 hits new high on six-day rally

Oil sank from a five-week high down almost five per cent after OPEC extended plans to limit production without deepening the cuts
  • 2 hours ago

OPEC’s cuts will likely end investor reluctance to buy oil stocks — but don’t expect a rally: analysts

Among the favourite stock picks by several equity analysts are large integrated Canadian oilsands players
  • 2 hours ago

Donald Trump considers congestion pricing for American cities

DONALD TRUMP made a splash during the American presidential campaign when he called for a trillion-dollar investment in infrastructure. But when he actually released his first major budget proposal this week, funds for roads and bridges hardly attracted notice. Though the document does lay out a target of $200bn in direct federal spending, to be augmented by private investments, it provides only $5bn in 2018. “President Trump’s campaign promises on infrastructure are crumbling faster than our roads and bridges,” said one senior Democrat.Yet tucked away in the proposal is one short paragraph that ought to intrigue the country’s city-dwellers, who overwhelmingly vote Democratic, as well as business travellers who often find themselves visiting American cities.In a paragraph titled “Incentivize Innovative Approaches to Congestion Mitigation”, there is a proposal to “provide valuable incentives for localities to think outside of the box in solving long-standing congestion challenges,” modeled after...Continue reading
  • 3 hours ago

These Are the Best Memorial Day Deals This Weekend

Here is a roundup of the best deals this holiday weekend.
  • 3 hours ago