Mazda MX-5 Grand Touring vs BMW 230i Convertible

Credit: bmwblog.com

A couple of days ago, I wrote an article about Mazda inviting journalists out to test its newest CX-5 crossover and the Japanese company brought along the BMW X1, as well as its competitors, to test the CX-5 against. While a big fan of Mazda, I felt this was a bit of an overreach, as I felt that very few, if any, customers would cross-shop both brands. However, it seems that we have a few BMW buyers in our audience that have, in fact, cross-shopped the BMW X1 with the new CX-5. So I thought it would be an interesting idea to see what other sort of BMW/Mazda comparisons we could do. So let’s see how the BMW 230i Convertible stacks up against the Mazda MX-5 Grand Touring.


The reason for choosing these two cars is that they both offer a similar amount of fun for a somewhat similar cost, though I’m playing fast and loose with the term “similar”. Grand Touring trim for the Mazda MX-5 starts life at $30,065. That’s the top of the line trim for the MX-5 and comes with 17″ wheels, heated leather seats, LED headlights, navigation and a Bose 9-speaker sound system, among other things. So it’s the nicest MX-5 you can get.



 


By comparison, the base price of the BMW 230i Convertible is $38,950, so already almost $10k more than the Mazda. For that, you also get 17″ wheels and leatherette seating but navigation is a $1,900 option, heated seats are a $500 option and the Harmon Kardon sound system is $875. So the Mazda actually comes slightly better equipped.


However, in terms of powertrain and performance, the BMW 230i Convertible leaves the Mazda MX-5 for dead. Under the hood of the Bimmer is a 2.0 liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine that makes 248 hp. That engine is mated to an eight-speed automatic gearbox as-standard and no manual transmission is available on the 230i ‘Vert, which is a shame. For the 230i Convertible, 0-60 mph happens in the low 5 second range, which is pretty quick.


By contrast, the Mazda MX-5 is a bit underwhelming, in terms of power. The little MX-5 packs a 2.0 liter normally-aspirated four-cylinder engine that only makes 155 hp and 148 lb-ft of torque. Those are tiny numbers compared to the BMW’s. But, thanks to its incredibly light weight and six-speed manual gearbox, the MX-5 can actually get from 0-60 mph in just under 6 seconds. So it’s not much slower than the 230i but it takes really revving the bolts off of its engine, whereas the turbocharged torque of the BMW makes easier work of going fast.



 


But these two cars are about top-down fun and putting a smile on their driver’s face. So performance times aren’t really relevant. What’s more important is how fun they are to drive and I think real car enthusiasts will have a tough time choosing the BMW 230i Convertible over the Mazda MX-5. It’s not that the BMW 2 Series is a bad driving car. Quite the contrary, actually, as the 230i Convertible is one of the most fun small, soft-top cars on the market. Its only issue is that the Mazda MX-5 is the most fun soft-top car on the market.


The MX-5 has a wonderful simplicity to it that’s impossible to beat. It’s so small and so light that it feels more like a glove fitting around the driver, rather than a big car enveloping the driver. It’s so lithe and nimble that it’s almost ridiculous. Then there’s the six-speed manual which is brilliant and far more fun than the eight-speed auto in the Bimmer, which is admittedly brilliant but a bit too anodyne here. The top of the Mazda is manually-operated, compared to the power-folding top of the Bimmer. Just unlatch the latch in the MX-5 and push the top back from the driver’s seat and the entire job is done in about five seconds.



BMW’s 230i Convertible does have its advantages, though. It’s more comfortable and far more spacious, as it actually has back seats, which the MX-5 does not. It’s more premium and built with better materials, making it the more luxurious choice for top-down cruising. However, I’d argue that any rear-wheel drive convertible sports car should be about driving pleasure first, especially cars with BMW and Mazda badges. In this regard, while also considering the $10k price cut and better as-standard equipment, I think my money would go toward the Mazda. But I’ll leave it to you readers, would any of you cross-shop these two cars and, if so, which would you choose?


The article Mazda MX-5 Grand Touring vs BMW 230i Convertible appeared first on BMW BLOG






Rolling Stone Magazine

Top Stories

7 Best Setting Sprays to Keep Your Makeup From Melting Off

Farewell, smudged and sweaty makeup.
  • 2 days ago
  • 12

With the Actros on the New Silk Road.

With a Mercedes-Benz Actros via Moscow, Samara and Tashkent, east along the mountains toward China.
  • 21 hours ago
  • 10

Turner BMW of Dane Cameron Captures Win at Lime Rock

The No. 96 BMW M235iR of Dane Cameron captured the Touring Car win Saturday morning on the 1.5-mile 7-turn Lime Rock Park with a ’nail … The article Turner BMW of Dane Cameron Captures Win at Lime Rock appeared first on BMW BLOG
  • 2 days ago
  • 9

ROWE Racing secures second place at the Nürburgring with the BMW M6 GT3

A dramatic and rain-soaked finale, soaring summer temperatures and 205,000 thrilled spectators: the 45th edition of the 24-hour race at the Nürburgring (GER) lived up … The article ROWE Racing secures second place at the Nürburgring with the BMW M6 GT3 appeared first on BMW BLOG
  • 2 days ago
  • 9

BMW recalls 45K older 7-series cars

BMW is recalling 45,484 2005-2008 7 Series model in the United States because the doors could open unexpectedly while being driven, the National Highway Traffic Safety … The article BMW recalls 45K older 7-series cars appeared first on BMW BLOG
  • 2 days ago
  • 9

Latest in Lifestyle

Guest article: Uncle Benz.

Confident performance. You can be seen anywhere with a 280 CE: the Coupé is timeless and popular.
  • 2 hours ago

Lucas Auer to line up in ADAC GT Masters

Lucas Auer will start for BWT Mücke Motorsport in the ADAC GT Masters at Spielberg.
  • 2 hours ago

Missing Bosch part slows BMW production

BMW said a shortage of steering gears supplied by Bosch slowed production of several of its models at its factories in South Africa and China. … The article Missing Bosch part slows BMW production appeared first on BMW BLOG
  • 12 hours ago

First BMW M4 CS reviews are in!

This past weekend, BMW handed out the keys to the M4 CS fleet to a few journalists from around the world who had the chance … The article First BMW M4 CS reviews are in! appeared first on BMW BLOG
  • 12 hours ago

Marc Girard, Head of BMW Concept Design talks about the 8 Series Coupe

Former head of BMW Interior Design and now in charge of the concept designs in Munich, Marc Girard, goes on camera to talks about the … The article Marc Girard, Head of BMW Concept Design talks about the 8 Series Coupe appeared first on BMW BLOG
  • 12 hours ago

Rendering: 2019 BMW 8 Series Gran Coupe Is a Stylish Proposition

The BMW 8 Series is no longer a rumor, or a silent whisper among enthusiasts wishing for a revival of the badge. No, the BMW … The article Rendering: 2019 BMW 8 Series Gran Coupe Is a Stylish Proposition appeared first on BMW BLOG
  • 16 hours ago

Video: Watch a BMW M4 Devour Three Tuned Hot Hatches on the Ring

Living next to the Nurburgring certainly seems like a dream to all of us currently residing in the US. The track where all BMWs are … The article Video: Watch a BMW M4 Devour Three Tuned Hot Hatches on the Ring appeared first on BMW BLOG
  • 16 hours ago

BMW 8 Series Concept Turned into Shooting Brake in New Rendering

The world is currently patiently waiting for BMW to go through the usual process of bringing out the final version of the 8 Series Concept … The article BMW 8 Series Concept Turned into Shooting Brake in New Rendering appeared first on BMW BLOG
  • 16 hours ago

Ute BMW 8 Series Concept Rendering Is a Step Too Far

We’ve seen quite a number of renderings of the BMW 8 Series come out lately. It’s understandable as there are few cars out there that … The article Ute BMW 8 Series Concept Rendering Is a Step Too Far appeared first on BMW BLOG
  • 16 hours ago

Dashboard-Voodoo.

The dashboard originates from an era when horses and riders still communicated with one another directly. The dashboard of the future will finally mark a return to intuitive communication.
  • 18 hours ago

How to Fix Bleach-Damaged Hair

By the time I hit elementary school, the white-blonde hair I’d had my entire childhood began to fade into darker blonde. And ever since then, I’ve strived to be as blonde as humanly possible—all while still maintaining my status as a person with hair on her head. As you can imagine, it’s a very delicate balance: Taking […]
  • 18 hours ago

With the Actros on the New Silk Road.

With a Mercedes-Benz Actros via Moscow, Samara and Tashkent, east along the mountains toward China.
  • 21 hours ago