Cathay Pacific Needs to Get in the Low Cost Carrier Game


Cathay Pacific

Other airlines have invested in low cost offshoots, but not Cathay Pacific. That may be a mistake, a Bloomberg columnist warns. Cathay Pacific

Skift Take: Cathay Pacific has had years to watch low cost airlines steal share from European legacy carriers. Asia has been a little behind Europe, but it's increasingly clear that Asian travelers also demand cheap flights with few frills. Cathay needs to give customers what they want, or it will be in trouble.

— Brian Sumers

What’s Europe’s most profitable airline?

Air France-KLM, whose premium passengers sleep in private suites with memory-foam mattresses, dine on Joël Robuchon dishes and have private jets at their disposal? Or Ryanair Plc, which offers flights starting at 10 euros ($11) and whose chief executive officer has mused about charging passengers for toilet visits?

No prizes for guessing it’s Ryanair. Trailing 12-month operating margins at the Irish budget carrier run at 23 percent, compared with 4.8 percent at Air France and 6.9 percent at Lufthansa AG. They have a bare-bones image, but discount airlines are where the best money is made. Of the world’s 10 most profitable airlines by operating margins, only Alaska Air Group Inc. and Delta Air Lines Inc. are full-service carriers.

There’s a lesson in that for Asia’s once-mighty full-service operators, Singapore Airlines Ltd. and Cathay Pacific Airways Ltd. Both have been relatively late to the discount-aviation party, and are now carrying out strategic reviews to address the threat from state-owned airlines in China and the Gulf.

Budget carriers were until relatively recently a smaller presence in Asia than in Europe and North America. Now they’re indisputably a major part of the future. Survival may depend on embracing the concept.

Singapore Air has been the most forthright in adopting this change. Its Tiger Airways budget offshoot was established back in 2004, with the long-haul discount carrier Scoot following in 2012. The eponymous main carrier’s share of group capacity fell to 76 percent last year, from 95 percent five years earlier.

Despite missteps and a delayed integration between Tiger and Scoot, discount flying as a whole is starting to pay off: SIA’s budget carriers have posted profits for six consecutive quarters. Absent earnings from them and SilkAir, the shorter-haul brand, the group as a whole would have reported a loss in fourth-quarter results announced Thursday.

While Singapore Air has been running to meet the future, Cathay Pacific has been standing athwart history, yelling Stop. It doesn’t have a budget line, and when Qantas Airways Ltd. and China Eastern Airlines Corp. attempted to set one up in Hong Kong in 2012, the result was a two-year regulatory battle that eventually sent the foreigners packing.

While Hong Kongers constantly moan about the high cost of Cathay’s tickets, the only local low-cost carrier seeking to undercut the incumbent is Hong Kong Express, ultimately controlled by mainland takeover monster HNA Group Co.

That conservatism worked well enough for Cathay in the past, but the tide can’t be halted. Already, travelers from Hong Kong to Southeast Asia can fly Tiger and Scoot, as well as AirAsia Bhd., Cebu Air Inc., and Qantas’s Jetstar affiliates. Jetstar is competing with ANA Holdings Inc.’s Peach and Vanilla Air on Japan routes, while Spring Airlines Co. and Juneyao Airlines Co. vie with HK Express to serve mainland China. Cathay is well on its way to posting a second consecutive year of losses; SIA, for all its travails, has made a profit every year since at least 1990.

Cathay’s newly crowned CEO Rupert Hogg would do well to learn from that comparison in addressing the carrier’s predicament. The long-haul routes where it’s traditionally dominated are looking increasingly like a lost cause, given the growing muscle of Chinese and Gulf airlines.

Regional routes are the best hope for sustained profits, and low-cost carriers are inevitably going to be fierce rivals there, too. Cathay can’t beat the competition — so it should take a leaf from Singapore Air’s book, and join it instead.

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Bloomberg LP and its owners.

David Fickling is a Bloomberg Gadfly columnist covering commodities, as well as industrial and consumer companies. He has been a reporter for Bloomberg News, Dow Jones, the Wall Street Journal, the Financial Times and the Guardian.

©2017 Bloomberg L.P.

This article was written by David Fickling from Bloomberg and was legally licensed through the NewsCred publisher network. Please direct all licensing questions to

Top Stories

Wellness Executives Question Hotel Chains’ Capabilities in the Sector

Everyone in hospitality, it seems, is focusing on more wellness offerings, whether through mergers and acquisitions, partnerships, or enhanced programming — but what do the wellness vets think? Does this trend have staying power or is it just a fad? -Deanna Ting
  • 11 hours ago
  • 12

Travel Habits of Americans: 42 Percent Aren’t Taking a Vacation This Summer

Unless there's a flood of last-minute vacation planners who will book trips in the coming days, weeks or months, many U.S. travelers are saying that they're hunkering down for another summer of little to no time away from the office. -Dan Peltier
  • 12 hours ago
  • 10

Air Canada Reverses Course, Leads the Charge to Bring Loyalty Back In-House

There was a trend over the last few years for airlines to try to spin off their loyalty programs into ... Read More
  • 6 hours ago
  • 9

What Ctrip Looks For When Buying Other Companies

Zhou's comments point to more deals for companies outside China, similar to the one for Skyscanner, and with plenty of money to spend it looks like it could be a very busy few years. -Patrick Whyte
  • 12 hours ago
  • 9

Visit Florida’s Budget Cuts Could Seriously Impact Florida’s Robust Meetings Business

How much of an impact the slashed Visit Florida budget will have on the state's meetings and conventions industry is an open question. The answer depends on whom you ask. -Deanna Ting
  • 11 hours ago
  • 9
farawayyachtingcharters - Easy Branches
botoxfillerveintheraphyinphuket - Easy Branches

Latest in Travel

Cathay Cuts 600 Jobs as It Tries to Get Costs Under Control

It might please investors to cut jobs but Cathy Pacific's problems run much deeper. It needs to work out where it fits in an airline environment that is rapidly changing. -Patrick Whyte
  • 43 minutes ago

Six skincare rules everyone should follow

Before you even consider reaching for your foundation or swiping on some mascara, it’s important to be confident and happy with your canvas – your skin. Our skin care needs and problems are totally unique to us but one thing is for certain: if you’re not looking after your skin it is going to be […] The post Six skincare rules everyone should follow appeared first on VOGUE India.
  • 3 hours ago

Team Vogue’s favourite fragrances might just inspire you to find new loves

Perfumes are the most emotion-inducing beauty products you’ll ever use. Your mum’s signature scent will always smell like home to you; your ex-boyfriend’s, an annoying reminder of a time that was and your own, your identity. Each of us at the Vogue HQ have our own favourites that we’ve come to be known by. Check […] The post Team Vogue’s favourite fragrances might just inspire you to find new loves appeared first on VOGUE India.
  • 3 hours ago

9 ways to power up mind, body and hair

Living a more balanced life is probably on almost everyone’s wish list but often it feels impossible to achieve. Scroll ahead through slideshow as we give you an ultimate guide to power up mind, body and hair. The post 9 ways to power up mind, body and hair appeared first on VOGUE India.
  • 3 hours ago

Launching Skift Business of Loyalty Newsletter: Why Loyalty Is Still Relevant to the Travel Industry

One would think that loyalty would be constant, but it is not. Our New Loyalty newsletter is here to help you make sense of the changing environment. -Grant Martin
  • 3 hours ago

American Express Expands Its Lounge Access Program With Its Platinum Card

Travelers who own the American Express card now have a new suite of lounges to look forward to visiting. Whether they make up for the annual fee on the AmEx platinum is another question. -Grant Martin
  • 3 hours ago

#BeautyGoals: Pink lips in every hue are the real MVPs this summer

Over the past week, Bollywood stepped out looking their best, pink pouts in tow. While Sonam Kapoor wore a balmy pink-coral hue, Kareena Kapoor Khan and Karisma Kapoor brought out their brights and Freida Pinto and Sonakshi Sinha took to creamy matte finishes. Kriti Sanon and Shraddha Kapoor’s hair game was on point with Sanon […] The post #BeautyGoals: Pink lips in every hue are the real MVPs this summer appeared first on VOGUE India.
  • 4 hours ago

The fresh way to sport embroidery this summer

Trade your all over embroidered pieces for appliqué—we are talking vibrant pops of detailing on your otherwise plain garment. From Delpozo to Kenzo, designers are loving this feminine trend. You can try the trend in all doses—from Gucci’s appliquéd denim jacket to a pair of embroidered loafers by Christian Louboutin. We are crushing over the […] The post The fresh way to sport embroidery this summer appeared first on VOGUE India.
  • 4 hours ago

The lip balms that need to be in your bag all year round

Lip balms are like house keys, they seem to vanish at the flicker of an eye – almost like they have a life of their own: parties to attend, boys to text, sample sales to scrummage. So it’s wise to keep a few handy. The good news? There’s no need to splash out on expensive […] The post The lip balms that need to be in your bag all year round appeared first on VOGUE India.
  • 4 hours ago

Here’s why you’ll love Viviane Sassen’s new photo book, ‘Roxanne II’

Dutch fashion and fine art photographer Viviane Sassen’s new photo book Roxanne II is like a gallery of earthly delights, full of pictures of Sassen and her muse, Roxanne, visually colliding to make vibrant and ethereal mutual portraits. The photographer’s presence is felt in the shadows and paint imprints on her muse’s skin in one […] The post Here’s why you’ll love Viviane Sassen’s new photo book, ‘Roxanne II’ appeared first on VOGUE India.
  • 4 hours ago

Aishwarya Rai Bachchan’s stylist talks about that giant Michael Cinco gown

Aishwarya Rai Bachchan went to Cannes, hit the red carpet like a pro, had a mother-daughter style moment and she is back. Each year the actor travels to the French Riviera to represent L’Oréal as a global ambassador and her sartorial choices on the red carpet become talking points for days after. We spoke Rai […] The post Aishwarya Rai Bachchan’s stylist talks about that giant Michael Cinco gown appeared first on VOGUE India.
  • 4 hours ago

10 travel accessories you need to buy before your next vacation

If you’re anything like us, you probably love summer trips—whether it’s a month-long vacation to an exotic isle with your partner or just a weekend getaway with the girls, we get seriously stoked every time a holiday is on the cards. While there’s nothing better than a vacation, most of us agree that travelling can […] The post 10 travel accessories you need to buy before your next vacation appeared first on VOGUE India.
  • 4 hours ago