7,000 FARC rebels are demobilizing in Colombia. But where do they go next?

Credit: washingtonpost.com

7,000 FARC rebels are demobilizing in Colombia. But where do they go next?

FARC guerrillas and civilians build barracks in the Transitional Standardization Zone in Pondores, La Guajira department, Colombia, on March 31. (Joaquin Sarmiento/ Agence France-Presse via Getty Images)

It took four years of negotiations, a “no” vote on a referendum for peace and a final framework that ultimately passed Colombia’s Congress. In January, the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) rebels began to disarm and demobilize.

After 52 years of guerrilla fighting, the FARC concentrated its estimated 7,000 troops in 26 designated localities. The peace plan calls for this disarmament process to run for 180 days. Former FARC members then begin their reintegration into civilian life.

But where will the former FARC guerrillas go? This matters.

My research on post-conflict environments reveals that most ex-combatants around the world go home. They generally return to their families to facilitate their reintegration and can then re-create civilian bonds that will rival their combatant ones.

Recruitment determines where “home” is

The geography of recruitment determines where former troops end up. Because some armed units operate close to home while others have been dispatched farther away from their recruits’ home areas, this policy of relocating home ends up keeping local units intact. Non-local fighting units end up weaker, though, as their members disperse away from the war zone.

This is an important distinction. Regions comprising locally based groups thus maintain a stable and peaceful balance of power. In contrast, regions where local groups neighbor nonlocal groups can more easily become unstable and see a return to organized violence and remilitarization. This is what happened with the demobilization of Colombia’s paramilitary groups in 2003-2006: Half of the units remilitarized.

The FARC may demobilize differently

The FARC may defy the trend of homeward-bound combatants, as many may stay in or near the disarmament areas. An estimated 20 percent of the guerrillas have no families to return to, having broken their ties to the outside and spent much of their lives within the FARC.

The vast majority of ex-combatants, however, will stay near the disarmament zones because this is the FARC’s plan. The FARC fears disappearing. It has ambitious political goals, which become impossible to achieve without its organization remaining intact. If its combatants disperse to their home towns, the FARC’s chances of competing politically at the national level would be jeopardized.

Accordingly, the FARC leadership was clever in negotiating the terms of reintegration of its combatants. Whereas some members of the government’s negotiating team sought individualized reintegration in localities of the ex-combatants’ choosing, the FARC managed also to negotiate the creation of ECOMUN, a FARC-run organization that will administer material assistance and economic projects for the ex-rebels collectively in their former strongholds. This increases the incentives for ex-combatants to stay put.

This geographic clustering will help commanders keep tabs on their rank and file. Accordingly, the FARC’s command and control, social networks and organizational structure will be preserved, potentially along with other assets such as their financial systems.

Who gains from this reintegration plan?

The FARC stands to gain, but there are broader benefits as well. Here are three likely outcomes:

1) Preserving the FARC’s presence in these territories averts the creation of power vacuums there, which invite violence because other illegal nonstate actors (remilitarized paramilitaries, drug cartels, gangs and still-active National Liberation Army rebels) seek to lay claim to the FARC’s turf.

2) Keeping the FARC intact and in its strongholds will facilitate its reincarnation as a political party. The disarmament zones coincide not only with the places in which the FARC exercised wartime influence over the population, but also with the localities slated for a large influx of reconstruction investment — and the FARC may be able to claim political credit.

3) Ex-FARC combatants may benefit from the intact social networks to facilitate their reintegration into civilian life in these territories. The FARC may serve as a source of psychological support and employment for former combatants in these territories, for instance.

But there are also risks

A key risk is that preserving the FARC’s organizational structure also means it has the capacity to remilitarize. This could play out like the “independent republics” after Colombia’s La Violencia from 1946-1958. When targeted with state-building, former guerrillas in these republics remilitarized, leading to the birth of the FARC and 52 years of civil war.

Similarly, the paramilitaries’ demobilization a decade ago left local units able to remilitarize. They did so when they neighbored weakening non-local groups and faced a shift in the balance of power in their territory.

A second risk is how the FARC will relate to the civilian population. If it continues with its coercive and authoritarian style, the populations of these territories — ex-combatants and civilians alike — could end up living under persistent, militarized, nondemocratic politics. The experience of paramilitary politics in Colombia suggests that legacies of coercive politics erode only very slowly.

And there’s a third big risk: Wartime networks are also correlated with ex-combatant criminality, especially if the mid-ranking commanders, stripped by demobilization of their war incomes and status, engage in crime and pull their rank and file with them.

It is also worth highlighting that only a few of the FARC’s wartime territories correspond with the disarmament zones. Where they do not, the FARC has left dangerous power vacuums. The state must immediately seek to fill these vacuums, deploying military force and police, but also social development programs, legal frameworks and infrastructure programs.

In the past, the state has proven incapable of filling such vacuums. Its commitment and resources this time around suggest now may be different. However, the state currently plans to equally prioritize all zones affected by the armed conflict, rather than focusing specifically on the places in which the FARC is weakening or disappearing and where vacuums are emerging. The state may find it difficult to build up governing capacity quickly enough and will thereby leave opportunities for further outbreaks of violence.

What is the outlook for the FARC’s reintegration, in light of these risks and benefits? To avert remilitarization, my past research has shown that it is necessary to either break up all armed units equally and immediately state-build in the territories or keep them intact equally to preserve the power balances among groups.

By preserving many FARC units, the current strategy has potential to avoid a return to organized violence. At the same time, Colombia’s government also faces significant new challenges, including filling power vacuums, reining in mid-ranking commanders and mitigating coercive politics.

Sarah Zukerman Daly is assistant professor of political science at the University of Notre Dame, where she researches political, criminal and ethnic violence and postwar politics. Her first book, “Organized Violence After Civil War: The Geography of Recruitment in Latin America,” was recently published by Cambridge University Press.

Rolling Stone Magazine

Top Stories

Google Doodle Honors American Indian Activist Richard Oakes

He led the occupation of Alcatraz Island in 1969
  • 5 days ago
  • 106

Family Looking for Man Who Saved Dog from American River

FAIR OAKS — Chuck the pit bull mix is actually well trained. Mom and daughter, Bing and Theresa Simard, have made sure of that. Which is why they didn’t see what happened Sunday coming. “It happened pretty quick. I didn’t realize he was going to go for it,” Theresa Simard said. Bing and Theresa were walking along the Sunrise boat launch, and everything was going fine, until all of a sudden Chuck spotted some ducks. “I could not hold it anymore, […]
  • 6 days ago
  • 44

Caltrans: Tanker Truck Explosion near Highway 99 in Atwater, Roads Closed

ATWATER — Fire crews are on the scene of a possible Tanker explosion in Atwater near Highway 99. Southbound Highway 99 is closed at Westside Boulevard due to the tanker fire at Applegate Road. Caltrans says to expect delays in the area. There is no estimated time for the roads to reopen. Massive fire in Atwater CA pic.twitter.com/wfVvWBNCa6 — Greg Pina Colada (@pina250) May 23, 2017
  • 4 days ago
  • 22

Justice League Director Zack Snyder Steps Down From Film After Daughter’s Suicide

Joss Whedon will step in while Snyder focuses on his family
  • 5 days ago
  • 21

Northbound Watt Avenue Closed at Arden after Car Hits Woman, 2 Kids

SACRAMENTO — A woman and two kids were hit by a car along Watt Avenue near Arden Way. It was not immediately known if the woman and children were in a crosswalk or what caused the crash. Northbound Watt Avenue was closed as police investigate. The conditions of the people hit were not immediately known.
  • 2 days ago
  • 20

Are You Looking for More?
Check this out ...


Latest in Regions

Joe Biden Urges Cornell Graduates to Stop ‘Living in Your Screens’

He also addressed the White House administration without referencing President Trump by name
  • 11 minutes ago

60-Year-Old Man Killed After Suspected Drunk Driver Fails to Stop at Red Light

SACRAMENTO — A 60-year-old man is dead after a suspected drunk driver caused a chain-reaction accident at a red light Friday night. Around 9:30 p.m. a 25-year-old male driver in a 2005 Ford F250 hit the rear of 2012 Honda Fit waiting at a red light on Elkhorn Boulevard and Watt Avenue. That car then hit the back of a 2011 Nissan Versa and they hit the back of a 2000 Acura Sedan. The right front passenger in the Honda […]
  • 1 hour ago

Gregg Allman of The Allman Brothers Band Dies at Age 69

SAVANNAH, Ga. (AP) — A publicist for rock legend Gregg Allman says the organist and singer for The Allman Brothers Band has died. He was 69. Ken Weinstein confirmed Saturday that Allman died at his home in Savannah, Georgia. Allman had cancelled some 2016 tour dates for health reasons. In March 2017, he canceled performances for the rest of the year. After years of substance abuse, Allman contracted hepatitis C and underwent a 2010 liver transplant. Born in Nashville, Tennessee, […]
  • 1 hour ago

Woman Held Captive by South Carolina Serial Killer Will Receive $25,000 Reward

She provided crucial information to help investigators with the case
  • 1 hour ago

Vietnam War Navy Pilot’s Remains Return to U.S. After More Than 50 Years

Lt. Cmdr. Frederick P. Crosby's body has come home to San Diego
  • 1 hour ago

Two South Carolina Men Charged for Forcing Alligator to Drink Beer

(CNN) — Two South Carolina men each face a harassment charge after pictures surfaced on social media showing them pouring beer down the throat of an alligator, authorities said. Joseph Andrew Floyd Jr., 20, and Zachary Lloyd Brown, 21, both of Ridgeland, are accused of harassing wildlife, the state’s Department of Natural Resources said in a news release. The incident took place on Wednesday in Jasper County, located in the coastal region in the southernmost part of the state. The […]
  • 2 hours ago

Hall of Fame Pitcher Jim Bunning Dies at 85

(LOUISVILLE, Ky.) — Hall of Fame Pitcher Jim Bunning, who went on to serve in Congress, has died. He was 85. Bunning’s death was confirmed by Jon Deuser, who served as chief of staff when Bunning was in the Senate. Deuser said he was notified about the death by Bunning’s family. Bunning won 224 games…
  • 2 hours ago

Report: Jared Kushner Back Channel With Russia Involved Syria

The intent was to connect Michael Flynn with Russian military leaders, the report says
  • 2 hours ago

Indian Army has domination over LoC and IB in J-K: Jaitley

The defence minister said India made every effort to create an environment for talks but then the attacks on Pathankot and Uri military bases had taken place.
  • 2 hours ago

Uma Bharti starts tour to inspect execution of 'Namami Gange' project

Speaking on the occasion Bharti stressed on the need to create awareness among people not to pollute the Ganga and make its water clean.
  • 2 hours ago

California Bills Target Private Business to Help Immigrants

SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — California Democrats are expanding their efforts to resist President Donald Trump’s crackdown on immigrants in the country illegally with bills aimed at limiting how much private businesses can cooperate with federal immigration authorities. Democrats control all levels of state government, and leaders have vowed to resist Trump administration policies at every turn. Immigration is among their key issues, but most legislation so far has been aimed at limiting what police can do to help immigration authorities […]
  • 3 hours ago